Treaty Renewal Presentation Extraction: Deck Claim Checks
On this page
- Key Takeaways
- What Should a Reinsurer Pull Out of a Broker's Renewal Deck?
- Which Renewal Deck Claims Need Data Before a Treaty Underwriter Relies on Them?
- How Should a Reinsurer Handle Four Common Renewal Deck Claims?
- What Do the Four Renewal Deck Cases Show Side by Side?
- What Process Handles Every Claim in a Treaty Renewal Deck?
- How Does Insurnest Help With Treaty Renewal Presentation Extraction?
- Key Terms
- Sources
- Frequently Asked Questions
Last reviewed: November 2026
Slide 6 of the broker's deck says the loss ratio improved to 58%. A footnote on slide 31 says "excluding catastrophe".
Including the year's storms, it was 71%. The underwriter who read slide 6 alone priced on the wrong number.
Treaty renewal presentation extraction is turning the claims in a broker's renewal deck into data an underwriter can test.
A deck is advocacy. Each claim on it needs the data behind it and, where that is missing, a question.
This guide gives you a claim-to-data-to-question table for eight common deck claims, four worked cases and a process.
Key Takeaways
- Every claim gets a slide number. Footnotes and appendices often change the headline.
- Ask for the basis. Loss ratios, rate changes and PMLs each have more than one.
- Same yardstick, both years. Compare like with like: same as-at date, same model version.
- Record the outcome. Write what you verified and what you priced on into the file.
What Should a Reinsurer Pull Out of a Broker's Renewal Deck?
A reinsurer should pull out of a broker's renewal deck every claim about performance or change, with its slide, figure and basis.
The cedent's side of this work, building the deck, is covered in reinsurer roadshow preparation. This guide reads it.
Which Renewal Deck Claims Need Data Before a Treaty Underwriter Relies on Them?
Renewal deck claims that need data first are those that change price or appetite. The table pairs each with its test.
| Deck claim | Data you need to verify it | Question to send |
|---|---|---|
| "Rates up 12% at renewal" | Rate change by class, split from exposure and terms changes | Please split the 12% into rate, exposure and terms by class |
| "Loss ratio improved to 58%" | Loss ratios by year, including and excluding cat, same as-at date | Please give loss ratios including cat for the same years |
| "Cat exposure reduced, PML down 15%" | PML on the same model version; sums insured by zone | Was the change from exposure or from the model version? |
| "Mix shifting to preferred risks" | Premium and sums insured by class and band, three years | Please send the risk profile for each of the last three years |
| "New MGA programme launched" | Programme premium, authority limits, early loss data | Please send the binding authority terms and premium estimate |
| "Reserves strengthened" | Average case outstanding by accident year and age; IBNR | Please send the average case outstanding triangle |
| "Underwriting tightened" | Guidelines before and after; referral counts | Please send old and new guidelines with the change date |
| "New pricing technology" | Go-live date; business written through it; rate adequacy | Which business went through the tool, and since when? |
How Should a Reinsurer Handle Four Common Renewal Deck Claims?
A reinsurer should handle common renewal deck claims by restating each on a basis it can price. The four cases below are illustrative.
How should a reinsurer handle a deck loss ratio of 58% ex-cat when it is 71% including cat?
A reinsurer should handle a 58% ex-cat loss ratio by putting a long-run catastrophe provision back in.
Earned premium was USD 200m. Non-cat losses were USD 116m (58%); cat losses added USD 26m, making USD 142m (71%).
Excluding cat is not wrong in itself. The CAS ratemaking text notes that ratemaking data often excludes catastrophe losses.
It replaces them with a provision for long-term expectations.
Here five years of cat ratios were 4%, 15%, 9%, 13% and 13%, averaging 10.8%.
Outcome: the price basis is 58% + 10.8% = 68.8%, not 58%. A modelled cat load can replace the average.
Record both figures. A loss ratio excluding catastrophe is only usable with its cat provision written next to it.
How should a reinsurer handle a claimed 12% rate increase when exposure also grew?
A reinsurer should handle a claimed 12% rate increase by separating rate from exposure growth.
Premium rose from USD 150m to USD 168m, which is 12%. Sums insured rose 9% over the same period.
The rate change per unit of exposure is 1.12 ÷ 1.09 − 1 = 2.75%.
The same CAS text says historical premium must be adjusted for past rate changes.
Otherwise projected premium is understated or overstated.
Outcome: use about 2.75% and ask for the class split. See risk-adjusted rate change tracking.
How should a reinsurer handle a deck claim that cat exposure fell 15%?
A reinsurer should handle a deck claim that cat exposure fell 15% by asking whether the model version changed.
The 1-in-200 PML fell from USD 400m to USD 340m, a 15% drop. The cedent had also moved to a new model version.
Rerun on the old version, the current portfolio gave USD 392m.
Exposure cut the PML by 2%; the model change made up the other 13 points.
Outcome: price on a consistent basis. See cat model input preparation.
How should a reinsurer handle a deck claim that reserves were strengthened?
A reinsurer should handle a deck claim that reserves were strengthened by testing the average case outstanding triangle.
The CAS study note on unpaid claims calls it a key diagnostic for changes in case reserve adequacy.
A falling pattern down a column points to possible weakening.
Here, average case outstanding at 24 months fell from USD 82,000 to USD 71,000.
That is a 13.4% fall across accident years 2021 to 2023. A change in claim mix could explain part of it, so ask.
Outcome: record the reserve strength claim as unverified, and load development until the triangle explains it.
See cedent reserves vs reinsurer reserves.
What Do the Four Renewal Deck Cases Show Side by Side?
The four renewal deck cases show that each headline needed a basis before it could be priced.
| Case | Deck says | Data shows | Priced on |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loss ratio | 58% | 71% including cat; 10.8% cat average | 68.8% |
| Rate change | +12% | Exposure +9% | About +2.75% |
| Cat exposure | PML −15% | Same model version: −2% | USD 392m PML |
| Reserves | Strengthened | Average case outstanding −13.4% | Unverified; development loaded |
What Process Handles Every Claim in a Treaty Renewal Deck?
The process that handles every claim in a treaty renewal deck has five steps, run before pricing starts.
Together they make treaty renewal presentation extraction repeatable across underwriters.
- Extract. List each claim with slide number, figure and stated basis.
- Classify. Map it to a row of the claim table above.
- Match. Find the data in the submission that tests it.
- Ask. Send unanswered claims to the broker as one numbered list.
- Record. Note what was verified and what was priced in the underwriting submission summary.
How Does Insurnest Help With Treaty Renewal Presentation Extraction?
Insurnest helps with treaty renewal presentation extraction through Reinsurance Email Intelligence.
It reads broker emails and attachments, including decks sent as PDFs, alongside loss runs and spreadsheets.
It extracts claims history, loss ratios, exposure, premium and structure into one structured view, and flags missing information.
It does not judge whether a deck claim is true or send questions to brokers. That judgement stays with the underwriter.
Key Terms
- Ex-cat loss ratio: A loss ratio that leaves out catastrophe losses, needing a cat provision before pricing.
- Risk-adjusted rate change: The change in price per unit of exposure, net of exposure and terms changes.
- Average case outstanding: Case reserves divided by open claims, used to test reserve adequacy.
Sources
- Casualty Actuarial Society: Basic Ratemaking (G. Werner and C. Modlin, 5th edition, May 2016)
- Casualty Actuarial Society: Estimating Unpaid Claims Using Basic Techniques (J. Friedland)
- Insurnest: Reinsurance Email Intelligence
Frequently Asked Questions
What should a reinsurer pull out of a broker's renewal deck?
A reinsurer should pull out of a broker's renewal deck every claim about performance or change, with its slide number, the figure stated and its basis.
Which renewal deck claims need data before a treaty underwriter relies on them?
Renewal deck claims that need data first include rate increases, improving loss ratios, reduced cat exposure, mix shift, new programmes, reserve strength, underwriting changes and new technology.
How should a reinsurer handle a deck loss ratio of 58% ex-cat when it is 71% including cat?
A reinsurer should handle a 58% ex-cat loss ratio by adding back a long-run cat provision. With a 10.8% average cat ratio, the price basis is 68.8%.
How should a reinsurer handle a claimed 12% rate increase when exposure also grew?
A reinsurer should handle a claimed 12% rate increase by removing exposure growth. Premium up 12% on exposure up 9% is a rate change of about 2.75%.
How should a reinsurer handle a deck claim that cat exposure fell 15%?
A reinsurer should handle a deck claim that cat exposure fell 15% by asking whether the model version changed. On the same version, the fall may be far smaller.
How should a reinsurer handle a deck claim that reserves were strengthened?
A reinsurer should handle a deck claim that reserves were strengthened by testing the average case outstanding triangle. A falling average can signal weakening instead.
What process handles every claim in a treaty renewal deck?
The process that handles every claim in a treaty renewal deck is extract, classify, match to data, ask through the broker, then record the outcome in the submission summary.
How does Insurnest help with treaty renewal presentation extraction?
Insurnest helps with treaty renewal presentation extraction by reading decks sent as PDFs, with other attachments, into one structured submission view that flags gaps.

Hitul Mistry
CEO, Insurnest
An InsurTech leader with more than a decade of experience across insurance and technology, focused on solving business problems with the help of technology. Has worked with brokers, insurance carriers, and reinsurance firms across the India, UAE, and US markets.
View LinkedIn profile →