Reinsurance Tender Management: Quote Grid & Audit Trail
On this page
- Key Takeaways
- What Is at Stake When a Cedent Runs a Reinsurance Tender?
- How Big Can the Gap Between Reinsurer Quotes Be After a Loss?
- What Should the Head of Reinsurance Fix First in Reinsurance Tender Management?
- What Does a Treaty Tender Timeline Look Like for a 1 January Renewal?
- What Audit Trail Should a Cedent Keep for Each Reinsurance Tender?
- How Will the CFO Know the Reinsurance Tender Worked?
- How Does Insurnest Support Reinsurance Tender Management?
- Key Terms
- Sources
- Frequently Asked Questions
Last reviewed: November 2026
"Why did we pay more than the second-cheapest quote?" The audit committee asked it after one windstorm used the whole cat layer.
The answer sat in the reinstatement terms, which nobody had put side by side with the rate on line.
Reinsurance tender management is how a cedent invites, normalises, compares and records reinsurer quotes for a treaty before binding.
Done well, it picks the quote that is cheapest across likely loss outcomes, and it leaves a record a board can follow.
This guide gives you a normalised quote comparison grid, a worked after-loss cost example, a tender timeline and an audit record.
Key Takeaways
- Normalise before you rank. Put rate on line, reinstatements, clauses, security and conditions on one basis.
- Price the loss year, not just the quiet year. The lowest deposit premium can be the dearest after one full loss.
- Run the tender to a dated timeline. Work back from inception so the wording is agreed before cover starts.
- Keep the audit trail as you go. Record who was invited, what each quoted and why the panel was chosen.
What Is at Stake When a Cedent Runs a Reinsurance Tender?
A reinsurance tender decides the price, the security and the contract certainty of a treaty for a full year.
The IAIS Insurance Core Principles (ICP 13.2.5) expect procedures to identify secure reinsurers.
Under Solvency II, Article 260 of Delegated Regulation 2015/35 covers actions to ensure the selection of suitable reinsurance.
This guide covers the treaty tender. For single risks, see facultative quote comparison for cedents.
How Big Can the Gap Between Reinsurer Quotes Be After a Loss?
The gap between reinsurer quotes after a loss can exceed the gap in their deposit premiums, because reinstatement terms differ.
Take an illustrative property catastrophe layer of USD 20m xs USD 10m, renewing on 1 January 2027, with three quotes.
What does a normalised quote comparison grid for a cat layer look like?
A normalised quote comparison grid for a cat layer puts each term that moves the cost on its own row, for every quote.
| Term to normalise | Quote A | Quote B | Quote C | Why it moves the cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rate on line | 9.5% | 10.5% | 10.0% | Sets the deposit premium on the USD 20m limit |
| Deposit premium | USD 1.90m | USD 2.10m | USD 2.00m | Paid whether or not a loss occurs |
| Reinstatements | 1 at 100% | 1 at 50% | 2 at 100% | Sets the extra premium after a loss and total cover |
| Total cover in the year | USD 40m | USD 40m | USD 60m | What is left for a second or third event |
| Hours clause | 72 hours windstorm | 72 hours windstorm | 72 hours windstorm, 168 hours flood | Decides how many events one storm becomes |
| Key clause difference | Expiring wording | Own cyber exclusion, wider than expiring | Expiring wording | A wider exclusion is less cover for the price |
| Financial strength rating | A- | AA- | A+ | Must meet your approved security list |
| Subjectivity | Final wording | None | Exposure update by 1 December | An open subjectivity can reopen the price |
| Quote validity | 14 days | 30 days | Until 15 December | An expired quote can be withdrawn |
All terms and ratings are illustrative.
Which reinsurance quote is cheapest after a loss?
The cheapest reinsurance quote after a loss is the one with the lowest deposit premium plus reinstatement premium for that loss.
All three are pro rata as to amount only: deposit premium × (loss ÷ USD 20m limit) × reinstatement rate.
| Outcome for the cedent | Quote A | Quote B | Quote C |
|---|---|---|---|
| No loss: total premium | USD 1.90m | USD 2.10m | USD 2.00m |
| USD 10m loss: reinstatement premium | 1.90 × 0.5 × 100% = USD 0.95m | 2.10 × 0.5 × 50% = USD 0.525m | 2.00 × 0.5 × 100% = USD 1.00m |
| USD 10m loss: total premium | USD 2.85m | USD 2.625m | USD 3.00m |
| USD 20m loss: reinstatement premium | 1.90 × 1 × 100% = USD 1.90m | 2.10 × 1 × 50% = USD 1.05m | 2.00 × 1 × 100% = USD 2.00m |
| USD 20m loss: total premium | USD 3.80m | USD 3.15m | USD 4.00m |
Quote A is USD 0.20m cheaper than Quote B in a quiet year. After one full-limit loss, it costs USD 0.65m more.
Quote C costs the most after one loss, but it is the only quote with cover left after a second full loss.
Weight these outcomes with your own cat model's probabilities. For time-adjusted terms, see reinstatement premium calculation.
What Should the Head of Reinsurance Fix First in Reinsurance Tender Management?
The Head of Reinsurance should fix the tender pack first in reinsurance tender management, so every reinsurer quotes the same thing.
Which terms must every reinsurer quote on the same basis?
Every reinsurer should quote structure, price, reinstatements, clauses, security and conditions on the basis set in the tender pack.
- Structure: Limit, retention, currency and period, exactly as in the pack.
- Price: Rate on line or rate on GNPI, minimum and deposit premium, and the adjustment basis.
- Reinstatements: Number, rate, and whether pro rata as to amount, time or both.
- Clauses: Hours clause, exclusions and each deviation from your model wording, listed one by one.
- Security: Rating agency, rating and date, checked against your approved security list.
- Conditions: Every subjectivity with its clearance date, plus the quote validity date.
Ask each reinsurer to mark changes from the expiring wording, as in expiring vs renewal treaty terms.
How many markets to invite is a reinsurance panel design decision, made before the pack goes out.
What Does a Treaty Tender Timeline Look Like for a 1 January Renewal?
A treaty tender timeline for a 1 January renewal starts in September and ends with agreed wording before inception.
| Date (illustrative) | Tender step | Owner | Record kept |
|---|---|---|---|
| 15 September | Approve structure, budget and invited markets | Head of Reinsurance, CFO | Signed tender scope |
| 1 October | Issue the tender pack through the broker | Placing broker | Pack version and recipient list |
| 31 October | Quotes due | Reinsurers via the broker | Each quote, dated as received |
| 7 November | Normalise quotes into the grid | Reinsurance analyst | Grid with normalisation notes |
| 21 November | Agree firm order terms and the panel | Head of Reinsurance, approver | Decision note and approval |
| 15 December | Confirm written lines, sign down if oversubscribed | Placing broker | Final shares by reinsurer |
| Before 1 January | Agree the final wording | Broker, legal, reinsurers | Agreed wording version |
ICP 13.2.13 asks for the formal contract ideally before inception: see reinsurance contract certainty.
What Audit Trail Should a Cedent Keep for Each Reinsurance Tender?
The audit trail a cedent should keep for each reinsurance tender is a dated record of every invitation, quote, comparison and decision.
TENDER RECORD: [Treaty] [Inception date]
Tender reference and tender pack version
Invited reinsurers and the reason for each invitation
Approved security list version used
Quotes received: reinsurer, date, version, validity
Normalisation notes: what was adjusted and why
Loss scenarios priced: no loss, partial loss, full limit
Decision: panel, shares, lead and the reason
Quotes not chosen: the reason for each
Approver, role and approval date
Subjectivities: cleared on [date] / still open
Bound terms vs firm order terms: differences found
Which tender decisions do boards and supervisors ask to see?
Boards and supervisors usually ask why the lead was chosen, why a cheaper quote lost and whether every reinsurer met security criteria.
ICP 13.2.16 says the supervisor should have access, on request, to material reinsurance documentation.
Test the bound treaty against the firm order with quoted vs bound terms reconciliation.
How Will the CFO Know the Reinsurance Tender Worked?
The CFO will know the reinsurance tender worked when the bound treaty matches the chosen quote and its after-loss cost was known.
- Comparability: Every quote sat on one grid, unchanged after the deadline.
- Loss-year cost: The decision note shows the cost after a full-limit loss.
- Security: Every signed reinsurer met the approved security list when bound.
- Certainty: Wording was agreed before inception and matches the firm order.
How Does Insurnest Support Reinsurance Tender Management?
Reinsurance Treaty Management does not run tenders, store ratings or route approvals. It starts once you bind.
It holds one digital treaty record of structure, shares, limits and commission rules, and applies configured formulas consistently.
It keeps an audit trail and controlled versions as terms change. Your team configures it and validates the results.
Key Terms
- Rate on line: Premium divided by the layer limit, shown as a percentage.
- Reinstatement premium: Extra premium paid to restore a layer's limit after a loss.
- Firm order terms: The final terms the cedent instructs the broker to bind.
Sources
- IAIS: Insurance Core Principles and ComFrame, December 2024 (ICP 13)
- EIOPA Solvency II Single Rulebook: Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/35, Article 260
- Insurnest: Reinsurance Treaty Management
Frequently Asked Questions
What is at stake when a cedent runs a reinsurance tender?
A reinsurance tender decides the price, security and contract certainty of a treaty for a full year, and it shows supervisors how the cedent selects suitable reinsurers.
How big can the gap between reinsurer quotes be after a loss?
The gap between reinsurer quotes after a loss can exceed the gap in deposit premiums, because reinstatement rates and the number of reinstatements differ between quotes.
Which reinsurance quote is cheapest after a loss?
The cheapest reinsurance quote after a loss is the one with the lowest deposit premium plus reinstatement premium for that loss, often not the lowest rate on line.
Which terms must every reinsurer quote on the same basis?
Every reinsurer should quote structure, price, reinstatements, clauses, security and conditions on the basis set in the tender pack, marking any deviation from the expiring wording.
What does a treaty tender timeline look like for a 1 January renewal?
A treaty tender timeline for a 1 January renewal runs from scope approval in September to quotes by October, firm order terms in November and agreed wording before inception.
What audit trail should a cedent keep for each reinsurance tender?
A cedent should keep a dated record of invited reinsurers, quotes received, normalisation notes, loss scenarios priced, the decision, rejected quotes, the approver and open subjectivities.
Which tender decisions do boards and supervisors ask to see?
Boards and supervisors usually ask why the lead was chosen, why a cheaper quote was rejected and whether every signed reinsurer met the security criteria on binding.
How will the CFO know the reinsurance tender worked?
The CFO will know the reinsurance tender worked when quotes shared one basis, the after-loss cost was known before binding and bound terms match the firm order.

Hitul Mistry
CEO, Insurnest
An InsurTech leader with more than a decade of experience across insurance and technology, focused on solving business problems with the help of technology. Has worked with brokers, insurance carriers, and reinsurance firms across the India, UAE, and US markets.
View LinkedIn profile →