Facultative Quote Comparison for Cedents: Beyond Price
On this page
- Key Takeaways
- What Is Facultative Quote Comparison for Cedents?
- Which Facultative Offers Should Be Excluded Before Scoring?
- How Should Facultative Offers Be Put on the Same Basis?
- What Does a Weighted Facultative Quote Scorecard Contain?
- How Do Three Facultative Offers Score on One Risk?
- When Does Each Facultative Offer Type Fit Best?
- How Does Insurnest Relate to Facultative Quote Comparison?
- What Can a Head of Outwards Reinsurance Change This Quarter?
- Key Terms
- Sources
- Frequently Asked Questions
Last reviewed: November 2026
Three facultative offers arrive for a large industrial risk on the afternoon before inception.
The cheapest one excludes flood, the most secure one costs more, and the underwriter needs an answer before the original policy incepts at midnight.
Facultative quote comparison for cedents is the structured review of reinsurer offers on one risk, scored on terms as well as price.
It works when offers are screened, put on the same basis and scored against weights set before the offers arrive, not after.
Key Takeaways
- Gates come before scores. An ineligible reinsurer should never reach the scorecard.
- Normalise first. Offers on different shares, currencies or commission bases cannot be ranked.
- Weights are set in advance. Choosing weights after seeing offers invites bias.
- The cheapest offer can cost most. One exclusion can leave a large part of a loss net.
- Splitting is an option, not a failure. Two strong partial offers can beat one weak full offer.
What Is Facultative Quote Comparison for Cedents?
Facultative quote comparison for cedents is the step between receiving reinsurer offers and signing down the placement on a single risk.
It sits with the outwards reinsurance team, often working through a broker. See the treaty vs facultative reinsurance guide for where fac fits.
The comparison has to be fast, because original inception dates rarely move.
It also has to be recorded, because auditors and regulators may ask why a reinsurer was chosen.
Which Facultative Offers Should Be Excluded Before Scoring?
The facultative offers that should be excluded before scoring are those failing a gate that no price can fix.
- Approved security list. The reinsurer is missing from the list or below the minimum rating.
- Regulatory eligibility. Local rules restrict who can be used, on what terms, or with what collateral.
- Sanctions and KYC. The counterparty has not cleared screening.
- Concentration limit. Accepting the offer would breach the cedent's limit for one reinsurer.
- Expired or conditional offer. The offer has lapsed or depends on information still outstanding.
Regulatory gates differ widely. Insurance Europe reports that India's rules require cedents to offer best terms first to reinsurers licensed in India.
It also reports collateral rules for cross-border reinsurers from IRDAI's May 2024 master circular, so check current local rules before scoring.
How Should Facultative Offers Be Put on the Same Basis?
Facultative offers should be put on the same basis by converting every offer to the same share, currency, premium basis and deduction set.
| Difference between offers | Example | Fix before scoring |
|---|---|---|
| Share versus 100% | One offer quotes premium for its share, another for 100% | Restate every offer per 1% share |
| Commission versus net rate | One gives a commission, another a net rate | Convert all to net cost after commission |
| Brokerage | Brokerage deducted in one offer only | Apply the same deduction to all |
| Currency | Offers in USD and local currency | Convert at one stated rate and date |
| Period | One offer is shorter than the original policy | Treat as a terms gap, not a price saving |
| Taxes and levies | Some include local taxes | Show taxes separately for every offer |
What Does a Weighted Facultative Quote Scorecard Contain?
A weighted facultative quote scorecard contains six criteria, a weight for each, and written anchors for the top and bottom scores.
| Criterion | Weight | Scores 5 when | Scores 1 when | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | 30% | Lowest net cost per 1% share | Highest net cost by a wide margin | Normalised offer |
| Security | 20% | Strong rating, stable outlook, no collateral needed | Weak rating or collateral required | Rating report, security list |
| Terms and exclusions | 20% | Fully back-to-back with the original policy | Exclusion or sublimit the original lacks | Slip checked against policy |
| Capacity | 15% | Takes the full share sought | Takes a small part of it | Written line |
| Claims service | 10% | Cash call clause and track record of fast settlement | Slow settlement history or no cash call | Claims history, clauses |
| Payment terms | 5% | Standard settlement terms | Tight premium payment warranty | Slip conditions |
These weights are illustrative. A cedent writing long-tail casualty may weight security higher, while a short-tail property team may weight claims service higher.
Terms scoring depends on checking the slip line by line. Our guide to reinsurance slip checking covers that step.
How Do Three Facultative Offers Score on One Risk?
Three facultative offers score differently once security, terms and capacity carry weight alongside price. The example is illustrative.
What do the three illustrative offers contain?
The three illustrative offers are for 50% of an industrial property risk with a sum insured of 80m and an original premium of 400,000 for 100%.
| Item | Reinsurer A | Reinsurer B | Reinsurer C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Share offered | 50% | 30% | 50% |
| Ceding commission | 20% | 25% | 22.5% |
| Rating | A+ | A- | BBB+ |
| Terms | Back-to-back | Flood excluded | Back-to-back |
| Payment | 60-day settlement | 60-day settlement | 30-day premium payment warranty |
Each 1% share carries 4,000 of original premium. Net cost per 1% is 3,200 for A, 3,000 for B and 3,100 for C.
For a 50% share, A costs 200,000 × 80% = 160,000 and C costs 200,000 × 77.5% = 155,000.
B's 30% costs 120,000 × 75% = 90,000, but leaves 20% still to place.
How are the weighted scores calculated?
The weighted scores are calculated by multiplying each criterion score by its weight and adding the results.
| Criterion | Weight | A | B | C |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | 0.30 | 3 → 0.90 | 5 → 1.50 | 4 → 1.20 |
| Security | 0.20 | 5 → 1.00 | 4 → 0.80 | 2 → 0.40 |
| Terms and exclusions | 0.20 | 4 → 0.80 | 2 → 0.40 | 4 → 0.80 |
| Capacity | 0.15 | 5 → 0.75 | 3 → 0.45 | 5 → 0.75 |
| Claims service | 0.10 | 4 → 0.40 | 4 → 0.40 | 3 → 0.30 |
| Payment terms | 0.05 | 4 → 0.20 | 4 → 0.20 | 2 → 0.10 |
| Total | 1.00 | 4.05 | 3.75 | 3.55 |
What does the result mean for the cedent?
The result means Reinsurer A wins, even though its net cost is 5,000 higher than C on the same 50% share.
That premium is 5,000 ÷ 155,000 = about 3.2% more for stronger security and no collateral question.
B scores well on price, but its flood exclusion would leave the cedent holding flood on 30% of the risk.
Would the ranking change with different scorecard weights?
The ranking would change with different scorecard weights, which is why weights must be fixed before offers arrive.
Move 10 points from terms to price, so price weighs 40% and terms 10%. A then scores 3.95, B scores 4.05 and C stays at 3.55.
B now wins, although its flood exclusion has not changed. The weights, not the offers, decided the outcome.
A team that sets weights after reading the offers can justify almost any choice.
When Does Each Facultative Offer Type Fit Best?
Each facultative offer type fits a different situation, so the scorecard result should be read with the placement context.
- Lowest net cost. Fits short-tail risks with strong, back-to-back offers from approved reinsurers.
- Strongest security at a premium. Fits long-tail or large risks where claims may be paid years later.
- Split placement. Fits when no single offer gives full capacity on clean terms, such as A's 50% shared with another strong line.
- Renegotiate before accepting. Fits when the best-priced offer fails only on one fixable term, such as B's flood exclusion.
Record the chosen offer, the scores and the reasons on the risk file.
That record also supports facultative cover expiry tracking and later facultative reinsurance accounting.
How Does Insurnest Relate to Facultative Quote Comparison?
Insurnest relates to facultative quote comparison on the other side of the transaction: submission intake at the reinsurer.
Reinsurance Email Intelligence reads broker submission emails and attachments together.
It extracts structure, premium, limits, claims history, exclusions and conditions.
It standardises these into one structured submission view and flags missing information, so reinsurers can quote with fewer queries.
It does not score offers, compare reinsurers or choose a placement. That judgement stays with the cedent's outwards team and its broker.
What Can a Head of Outwards Reinsurance Change This Quarter?
A head of outwards reinsurance can change three habits this quarter without new systems.
- Publish the weights. Agree scorecard weights by line of business before the next fac request goes out.
- Write the gates down. List security, eligibility and concentration gates in one page the team can apply.
- Review last quarter's placements. Check how many chosen offers carried terms gaps that nobody scored.
- Store the scorecard. Keep each completed scorecard with the risk file for audit.
Key Terms
- Back-to-back: Facultative terms that match the original policy in cover, limits and period.
- Net cost: Ceded premium for the share accepted, less ceding commission.
- Premium payment warranty: A condition that premium must be paid by a set date or cover may be affected.
- Cash call clause: A clause letting the cedent request early payment of a large claim.
Sources
- Insurance Europe: Market access and trade barriers faced by European insurers and reinsurers in foreign jurisdictions: India (June 2025)
- Insurnest: Reinsurance Email Intelligence
Frequently Asked Questions
What is facultative quote comparison for cedents?
Facultative quote comparison for cedents is the structured review of reinsurer offers on a single risk, scoring each one on price, capacity, security, terms, claims service and payment conditions. The aim is to choose the offer that protects the original policy best, not simply the cheapest one.
Why should cedents not choose facultative offers on price alone?
Cedents should not choose facultative offers on price alone because a cheaper offer can carry weaker security, smaller capacity or an exclusion the original policy does not have. Any gap leaves the cedent paying that part of a loss, which can cost far more than the premium saved.
How do you compare facultative reinsurance quotes?
To compare facultative reinsurance quotes, remove offers that fail security or eligibility gates, put the rest on the same share, currency and commission basis, score each on weighted criteria, then check the result against the net cost difference before choosing or splitting the placement.
What weights should a facultative quote scorecard use?
A facultative quote scorecard can use weights such as price 30%, security 20%, terms and exclusions 20%, capacity 15%, claims service 10% and payment terms 5%. These weights are illustrative, so each cedent should set its own to match its risk appetite and line of business.
How is the net cost of a facultative offer calculated?
The net cost of a facultative offer is the ceded premium for the share accepted, minus the ceding commission. For example, a 50% share of a 400,000 original premium is 200,000, and with a 20% commission the net cost is 160,000.
What is a back-to-back gap in facultative reinsurance?
A back-to-back gap in facultative reinsurance is any difference between the original policy and the facultative terms, such as an extra exclusion, lower sublimit or different period. The cedent keeps that exposure net, often without realising it until a claim is presented.
When should a cedent split a facultative placement between reinsurers?
A cedent should split a facultative placement when no single offer gives full capacity on acceptable terms, or when concentration on one reinsurer is too high. Splitting adds administration, so each additional reinsurer should bring capacity, security or terms the others do not.
Does Insurnest compare facultative quotes for cedents?
Insurnest does not compare facultative quotes for cedents. Reinsurance Email Intelligence works on the reinsurer side of submission intake, extracting structure, premium, limits, claims history, exclusions and conditions from broker emails and attachments, and flagging missing information before underwriting starts.

Hitul Mistry
CEO, Insurnest
An InsurTech leader with more than a decade of experience across insurance and technology, focused on solving business problems with the help of technology. Has worked with brokers, insurance carriers, and reinsurance firms across the India, UAE, and US markets.
View LinkedIn profile →