Reinsurance

Reinsurance Purchase Rationale: Template and Worked Record

On this page

Last reviewed: November 2026

"Renewed as expiring." Those three words were the whole rationale on file when the supervisor asked why the property treaty was bought.

The cedent had good reasons. It had simply never written them down in one place.

A reinsurance purchase rationale is a dated record of why a cedent bought a treaty in its current form, and who approved it.

It joins the reinsurance strategy, the risk appetite and the price paid, so a board or regulator can follow the decision.

This guide gives you a copy-ready purchase rationale template, a filled example for a raised retention and upkeep rules.

Key Takeaways

  • One record per treaty, per renewal. Write it before binding, not when someone asks.
  • Tie every purchase to a number in the risk appetite. Show the figure before and after the treaty.
  • Show the options you rejected. A rationale with one option is a description, not a decision.
  • Price the bad year as well as the average. Premium saved means little without the volatility kept.

Why Do Regulators Expect a Written Reason for Each Treaty Purchase?

Regulators expect a written reason for each treaty purchase because supervisory standards ask cedents to explain what reinsurance does.

The IAIS Insurance Core Principles (ICP 13.1.1) ask strategies to state the objectives pursued by using reinsurance.

ICP 13.1.2 points to risk appetite, both gross limit and net retention, and to the appetite for credit risk posed by reinsurers.

ICP 13.1.5 makes the board responsible for approving the reinsurance strategy. Senior management develops it.

In the EU, Article 260 of Delegated Regulation 2015/35 puts reinsurance in the risk-management policy.

That policy must cover selecting suitable reinsurance, judging which techniques fit the risks, and assessing their credit risk.

What Should a Reinsurance Purchase Rationale Record Contain?

A reinsurance purchase rationale record should contain nine numbered parts, completed for each treaty at each renewal.

Copy this purchase rationale template and keep the numbering, so every treaty file reads the same way.

REINSURANCE PURCHASE RATIONALE
Treaty:                 [name, type, layer, period]
Record ID / version:    [ID] v[n]     Date: [dd Month yyyy]

1. Objective            [capital relief / earnings volatility /
                         capacity / single-risk protection]
2. Link to risk appetite [metric, limit, figure before and after]
3. Options considered   [A renew as expiring / B changed structure
                         or retention / C no purchase]
4. Cost vs benefit      [premium, expected recoveries, capital
                         effect, 1-in-10 net result per option]
5. Retention choice     [retention chosen, why, what changed]
6. Counterparty selection [criteria, panel, largest share,
                         concentration check, exceptions]
7. Residual risks       [exclusions, gaps, basis and credit risk]
8. Approvals            [prepared by / reviewed by CRO /
                         approved by board or committee, dates]
9. Review trigger       [next review date and events that reopen]

How Should Each Part of the Purchase Rationale Record Be Completed?

Each part of the purchase rationale record should be completed with figures and dates, not adjectives such as "adequate" or "prudent".

The four parts below are the ones supervisors test most often.

You link a treaty's objective to the risk appetite by naming the metric, its limit and the figure before and after the treaty.

For example: "Net loss from any one risk: limit 2% of own funds; gross 6.25%; net after treaty 1.88%."

Which options should a cedent show it considered before buying?

A cedent should show at least three options considered: renew as expiring, a changed structure or retention, and no purchase.

Give each option its premium and its net result in an average and a bad year. A rejected option needs one line saying why.

How do you show cost against benefit for a retention choice?

You show cost against benefit for a retention choice by setting the premium saved against the extra losses kept.

Use two figures: expected extra retained loss, and extra retained loss in a bad year such as 1-in-10.

The method for picking the level itself is covered in optimal reinsurance retention.

Capital effects sit in cost of reinsurance vs cost of capital.

What belongs in the counterparty selection section?

The counterparty selection section holds the approved security criteria used, the panel, the largest share and concentration check.

ICP 13.2.6 lists bases for security criteria, including external opinions, minimum capital and levels of retrocession.

Record any reinsurer accepted outside your list, with the approver. Panel shape is a reinsurance panel design question.

What Does a Filled-In Rationale Look Like for Raising a Retention to USD 7.5m?

A filled-in rationale for raising a retention to USD 7.5m records the premium saved, the losses kept and why the appetite still holds.

Take an illustrative property per risk excess of loss treaty, renewing on 1 January 2027, for a cedent with USD 400m of own funds.

REINSURANCE PURCHASE RATIONALE
Treaty:        Property per risk XoL, 1 Jan - 31 Dec 2027
Record ID:     PR-PROP-2027 v1     Date: 2 December 2026

1. Objective   Limit net loss from any one risk; earnings
               volatility within plan
2. Appetite    Net any-one-risk limit 2% of own funds
               (USD 8.0m). Largest gross risk USD 25m (6.25%).
               Net after treaty USD 7.5m (1.88%): within limit
3. Options     A: USD 20m xs 5m, premium USD 4.00m
               B: USD 17.5m xs 7.5m, premium USD 2.90m (chosen)
               C: no purchase: gross USD 25m breaches appetite
4. Cost vs     B saves USD 1.10m premium vs A. Expected extra
   benefit     retained loss USD 0.75m. 1-in-10 year: four
               losses above USD 7.5m keep USD 10.0m more
5. Retention   USD 7.5m: within the USD 8.0m limit with
               USD 0.5m headroom; capital now supports it
6. Security    6 reinsurers, all on approved list; largest
               share 25%; no exceptions
7. Residual    Losses USD 5m-7.5m now fully net
8. Approvals   Head of Reinsurance; CRO review 25 Nov 2026;
               Risk Committee approval 1 Dec 2026
9. Review      1 Oct 2027, or if own funds fall below USD 375m

What did the cedent save and what extra volatility did it keep?

The cedent saved USD 1.10m of premium (USD 4.00m − USD 2.90m) and kept USD 0.75m of expected extra losses.

The expected gain is USD 0.35m a year (USD 1.10m − USD 0.75m).

In a 1-in-10 year, four losses above USD 7.5m each keep USD 2.5m more: 4 × USD 2.5m = USD 10.0m.

Net of the premium saved, that year is USD 8.9m worse than option A (USD 10.0m − USD 1.10m).

The review trigger matters. Below USD 375m of own funds, 2% is USD 7.5m, so the headroom is gone.

All figures are illustrative. Use your own loss data and capital model.

Who Owns the Purchase Rationale After Binding?

The Head of Reinsurance owns the purchase rationale after binding, and the CRO reviews it.

Board approval comes from the board or its risk committee, as ICP 13.1.5 expects.

  • Version on every change: A mid-term amendment to retention or limits needs a new version, not an edit.
  • Review at least yearly: Use the record as the starting point for the next renewal.
  • Re-open on triggers: A capital fall, a new class or a reinsurer downgrade restarts parts 2, 5 or 6.
  • Keep it findable: File it with the reinsurance programme summary for that year.

The annual check of performance against objectives belongs in the annual treaty review pack.

How Does Insurnest Fit Around a Reinsurance Purchase Rationale?

Reinsurance Treaty Management does not write the rationale, store documents or record approvals.

It holds the bound treaty the rationale refers to: structure, retention, limits, thresholds, shares and commission rules.

Controlled versioning and an audit trail show when the retention moved from USD 5m to USD 7.5m and what changed.

Results are only as good as the configuration, which your team validates.

Key Terms

  • Purchase rationale: A dated record of why a treaty was bought in its current form, and who approved it.
  • Risk appetite: The amount and type of risk a firm is willing to keep, with stated limits.
  • Retention: The loss a cedent keeps before a treaty responds.

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do regulators expect a written reason for each treaty purchase?

Regulators expect a written reason for each treaty purchase because supervisory standards ask cedents to show what reinsurance is for, how it fits risk appetite and how reinsurers were chosen.

What should a reinsurance purchase rationale record contain?

A reinsurance purchase rationale record should contain the objective, link to risk appetite, options considered, cost vs benefit, retention choice, counterparty selection, approvals, review trigger and date.

How do you link a treaty's objective to the risk appetite?

You link a treaty's objective to the risk appetite by naming the appetite metric, its limit, and the figure before and after the treaty, so the gap the treaty closes is visible.

Which options should a cedent show it considered before buying?

A cedent should show at least three options considered before buying: renew as expiring, a changed structure or retention, and no purchase, each with its cost and net effect.

How do you show cost against benefit for a retention choice?

You show cost against benefit for a retention choice by setting the premium saved against expected extra retained losses and against the extra retained loss in a bad year.

What belongs in the counterparty selection section?

The counterparty selection section holds the security criteria applied, the panel chosen, the largest single share, the concentration check and any reinsurer accepted as an exception.

What did the cedent save and what extra volatility did it keep?

In the illustrative example, the cedent saved USD 1.10m of premium, kept USD 0.75m of expected extra losses, and accepted up to USD 10m more retained loss in a 1-in-10 year.

Who owns the purchase rationale after binding?

The Head of Reinsurance owns the purchase rationale after binding, the CRO reviews it, and the board or its risk committee approves it, with a dated review at least once a year.

Hitul Mistry

Hitul Mistry

CEO, Insurnest

An InsurTech leader with more than a decade of experience across insurance and technology, focused on solving business problems with the help of technology. Has worked with brokers, insurance carriers, and reinsurance firms across the India, UAE, and US markets.

View LinkedIn profile →
ShareLinkedInX

Read our latest blogs and research

Featured Resources

Reinsurance

Optimal Reinsurance Retention: A Balance Sheet Guide

Optimal reinsurance retention explained: balance ceded margin, capital cost and earnings volatility, with a worked comparison of five retention options.

Read more
Reinsurance

Reinsurance Programme Summary: A One-Page Board View

Reinsurance programme summary template for boards: a filled one-page example, what each field means, where it comes from and how to keep it current all year.

Read more
Reinsurance

Cost of Reinsurance vs Cost of Capital: A CFO Framework

Cost of reinsurance vs cost of capital explained for CFOs: how to measure reinsurer margin, net capital relief and hurdle rates, with a worked ceding example.

Read more

Meet Our Innovators:

We aim to revolutionize how businesses operate through digital technology driving industry growth and positioning ourselves as global leaders.

circle basecircle base
Pioneering Digital Solutions in Insurance

Insurnest

Empowering insurers, re-insurers, and brokers to excel with innovative technology.

Insurnest specializes in digital solutions for the insurance sector, helping insurers, re-insurers, and brokers enhance operations and customer experiences with cutting-edge technology. Our deep industry expertise enables us to address unique challenges and drive competitiveness in a dynamic market.

Get in Touch with us

Ready to transform your business? Contact us now!

We respond within one business day.