Annual Treaty Review Pack: A Section-by-Section Template
On this page
- At a Glance
- What Is an Annual Treaty Review Pack?
- What Goes in Section 1: Terms and Amendments?
- What Goes in Section 2: Financial Performance?
- What Goes in Section 3: Claims and Structure Fit?
- What Goes in Sections 4 and 5: Security, Operations and Recommendation?
- How Do You Keep the Annual Treaty Review Pack Current?
- Which Pack Sections Should You Build Before Next Year's Review?
- Key Terms
- Sources
- Frequently Asked Questions
Last reviewed: November 2026
Every year someone rebuilds the treaty review pack from emails, old slips and finance extracts.
By the time it is ready, the renewal conversation has already started without it.
An annual treaty review pack sets out each treaty's terms, results, claims, structure fit and security in one standard document.
Built from a controlled treaty record, it lets cedents and reinsurers review performance before renewal pressure starts.
At a Glance
| Pack section | Question it answers | Main owner |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Terms and amendments | What did we agree, and what changed? | Reinsurance operations |
| 2. Financial performance | What did the treaty cost and return? | Reinsurance accounting |
| 3. Claims and structure fit | Did the treaty protect what it should? | Claims and actuarial |
| 4. Security and operations | Who carried the risk, and how smoothly did it run? | Reinsurance and risk |
| 5. Recommendation | Renew, adjust, restructure or re-market? | Head of Reinsurance |
What Is an Annual Treaty Review Pack?
An annual treaty review pack is the yearly performance review for one treaty or programme.
It is used internally and, in summary form, with the reinsurers or the cedent.
It is not a renewal submission. It looks back honestly, so the renewal can look forward with evidence.
Who uses the pack, and why?
The pack is used by the Head of Reinsurance, the CUO, the CRO and finance, and often by a board or reinsurance committee.
Supervisors expect the discipline behind it. The IAIS's April 2026 peer review of ICP 13 sets out Standard 13.1.
Under it, supervisors require cedents to have a reinsurance programme appropriate to their business and part of their risk and capital strategies.
Standard 13.2 requires effective internal controls over implementing that programme. A yearly review pack is practical evidence of both.
What Goes in Section 1: Terms and Amendments?
Section 1 of the annual treaty review pack records what was agreed and every change since.
| Field | Purpose | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Treaty ID and name | Unique reference used in every other section | Treaty record |
| Structure and class | Quota share, surplus, per risk XL, cat XL or stop loss | Treaty record |
| Period and territory | Confirms what the review covers | Treaty record |
| Ceded share and participations | Each reinsurer's percentage | Treaty record |
| Retention, limits and thresholds | The protection actually bought | Treaty record |
| Commission structure and formula | Flat, sliding scale or profit commission terms | Treaty record |
| Settlement frequency and conditions | How and when accounts settle | Treaty record |
| Amendments in the year | Each change, its effective date and reason | Versioned treaty terms |
Why must the pack show amendment history?
Amendment history matters because results only make sense against the terms in force at the time.
A mid-year change to commission or a limit can alter the whole year's economics.
Our guide to the reinsurance treaty register explains how to hold this history in one place.
What Goes in Section 2: Financial Performance?
Section 2 shows what the treaty cost the cedent and returned to the reinsurers.
Every figure should state its basis, written or earned, and the date it was measured at.
| Field | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Subject premium (GWP) | Size of the underlying portfolio |
| Ceded premium | What was paid for the protection |
| Ceding commission | What came back to the cedent |
| Ceded claims paid and outstanding | What the treaty paid or still owes |
| Ceded loss ratio | Claims as a share of ceded premium |
| Settlement position | Balances due, settled and overdue |
How should the pack show the treaty's economics?
The pack should show the treaty's economics with a simple check that both sides can follow.
Here is an illustrative, hypothetical quota share.
| Line | Calculation | Amount (USD) |
|---|---|---|
| Subject premium (GWP) | Given | 50,000,000 |
| Ceded premium | 50,000,000 × 40% ceded share | 20,000,000 |
| Ceding commission | 20,000,000 × 30% | 6,000,000 |
| Ceded incurred claims | Paid plus outstanding | 12,000,000 |
| Ceded loss ratio | 12,000,000 ÷ 20,000,000 | 60% |
| Claims plus commission ratio | (12,000,000 + 6,000,000) ÷ 20,000,000 | 90% |
At 90%, the reinsurers keep 10% of ceded premium before their own expenses.
That margin is what both sides will discuss at renewal, so the pack should show it plainly.
What Goes in Section 3: Claims and Structure Fit?
Section 3 shows whether the treaty protected what it was meant to protect.
| Field | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Large losses | Each loss above a set threshold, with the ceded amount |
| Limit and attachment use | How often layers were hit and how much limit was used |
| Reinstatements used | Remaining capacity and the cost of reinstatement |
| Development | How prior years' losses have moved |
| Portfolio change | Shifts in mix, geography or sums insured since placement |
How do you tell if the structure still fits the portfolio?
The structure still fits the portfolio when attachments, limits and cessions match today's exposure, not last year's.
Warning signs include layers never touched, layers exhausted early, or growth in segments the treaty barely covers.
Our guide to treaty structures that no longer match the portfolio explains how that drift builds up over several renewals.
The market matters too. Howden's 1.1.2026 renewal report said attachments remain elevated by historical standards.
The same report said terms and conditions are tighter. Section 3 should show how those changes affected this treaty.
What Goes in Sections 4 and 5: Security, Operations and Recommendation?
Sections 4 and 5 cover who carried the risk, how smoothly the treaty ran, and what should happen next.
What security and operations fields belong in the pack?
The security and operations fields show counterparty risk and the quality of administration.
| Field | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Panel and shares | Who carried the risk, and in what proportion |
| Financial strength ratings | Current rating of each reinsurer |
| Collateral | Security held, where required |
| Bordereaux and account timeliness | Whether data and accounts arrived on time |
| Queries and disputes | Open issues and how they were resolved |
How should the recommendation page be written?
The recommendation page should give one of four decisions for each treaty, backed by evidence from earlier sections.
| Decision | When it fits |
|---|---|
| Renew as is | Results acceptable and the structure still fits |
| Adjust terms | Structure fits, but price, commission or conditions need to change |
| Restructure | Attachments, limits or cessions no longer match the portfolio |
| Re-market | Panel, service or security concerns |
Our guide to renewal decisions based on incomplete bordereaux shows why the evidence base matters.
How Do You Keep the Annual Treaty Review Pack Current?
The annual treaty review pack stays current when its sections are refreshed through the year rather than rebuilt in one rush.
| When | What to update | Owner |
|---|---|---|
| On every amendment | Section 1 terms and amendment log | Reinsurance operations |
| Quarterly | Section 2 financials and settlement position | Reinsurance accounting |
| Quarterly | Section 3 large losses and limit use | Claims and actuarial |
| Half-yearly | Section 4 security and operations | Reinsurance and risk |
| About T-120 before renewal | Section 5 draft recommendation | Head of Reinsurance |
Which data checks should come first?
The first data checks are the ones that make every section agree with the others.
Ceded premium should match finance, participations should total 100%, and terms should match the latest version.
Where does Insurnest fit in the review pack?
Insurnest fits Section 1 and the calculations behind Section 2. Treaty Management holds one record per treaty.
That record covers structure, ceded share and participations, retention, limits, commission formulas, terms and settlement conditions.
Configured calculation rules, such as ceded premium as GWP × ceded share, produce calculation results.
Treaty terms are versioned as amendments occur, and calculation history stays linked to the logic used.
Audit review covers treaty information, changes and calculation history.
It does not manage claims, send alerts or answer questions about the treaty. Accuracy depends on configured terms and source data, so teams validate both.
Which Pack Sections Should You Build Before Next Year's Review?
You should build the sections that are hardest to reconstruct first. For most teams, that is the terms and amendment log.
- Set up Section 1 for every treaty now, and log amendments as they happen.
- Agree the basis and as-at date for every Section 2 figure.
- Fix a large-loss threshold for Section 3 for each class.
- Refresh Section 4 security data at least half-yearly.
- Draft recommendations by about T-120, so they shape the renewal rather than follow it.
- Bring the pack into treaty renewal scenario rooms as the starting evidence.
Key Terms
- Treaty review pack: A standard yearly document reviewing one treaty's terms, results and fit.
- Amendment log: A dated record of every change to treaty terms and the reason for it.
- Ceded loss ratio: Ceded claims divided by ceded premium.
- Ceding commission: The amount a reinsurer pays back to the cedent, usually as a share of ceded premium.
- Limit utilisation: How much of a layer's limit losses have used in a period.
- Reinstatement: Restoring an excess of loss limit after a loss, often for an extra premium.
Sources
- IAIS: Peer review of reinsurance and other forms of risk transfer relative to the standards set out in ICP 13 (April 2026)
- Howden: Howden's renewal report at 1.1.2026: Re-balancing (2 January 2026)
- Insurnest: Treaty Management
Frequently Asked Questions
What is an annual treaty review pack?
An annual treaty review pack is a standard yearly document that reviews one reinsurance treaty or programme. The pack covers agreed terms and amendments, financial results, claims, structure fit, panel security, operational quality and a recommendation, so cedents and reinsurers can discuss performance using the same evidence.
Why do cedents need an annual treaty review pack?
Cedents need an annual treaty review pack because renewal decisions made without a structured look back tend to repeat last year's structure. The pack shows whether the treaty still fits the portfolio, what it really cost and which issues need fixing, before renewal pressure narrows the options.
What should an annual treaty review pack include?
An annual treaty review pack should include five sections: terms and amendments, financial performance, claims and structure fit, security and operations, and a recommendation. Each figure needs a stated basis and as-at date, and every amendment should show its effective date and the reason for the change.
Who prepares the annual treaty review pack?
The annual treaty review pack is usually coordinated by the Head of Reinsurance. Reinsurance operations own the terms, accounting owns financials, claims and actuarial own losses and structure fit, and risk owns security. The CUO and Head of Reinsurance then agree the recommendation for each treaty.
Which ratios belong in a treaty review pack?
A treaty review pack should include the ceded loss ratio, the claims plus commission ratio, limit and attachment utilisation, reinstatements used and the share of accounts settled on time. Showing each ratio over several years, on a stated basis, makes trends visible and avoids arguments about definitions.
Can software build an annual treaty review pack?
Software can supply the most reliable parts of an annual treaty review pack, such as versioned treaty terms, amendment history and calculation results from configured treaty rules. People still interpret results, judge structure fit and write the recommendation, and teams must validate the configured terms and source data.
How is a treaty review pack different from a renewal submission?
A treaty review pack looks back at how an existing treaty performed and is used for internal decisions and honest discussion with counterparties. A renewal submission presents the cedent's risk to the market for the next period. A good review pack makes the submission faster and more credible.
When should the treaty review pack be finished before renewal?
The treaty review pack should have a draft recommendation around 120 days before renewal, so it shapes the renewal strategy rather than following it. Financial and claims sections can be refreshed quarterly through the year, leaving only a final update once the latest quarter closes.

Hitul Mistry
CEO, Insurnest
An InsurTech leader with more than a decade of experience across insurance and technology, focused on solving business problems with the help of technology. Has worked with brokers, insurance carriers, and reinsurance firms across the India, UAE, and US markets.
View LinkedIn profile →