Rate Checks on Reinsurance Bordereaux: Rule Spec & Example
On this page
- Key Takeaways
- Why Do Rate Checks on Reinsurance Bordereaux Work at Policy Level?
- What Fields Does a Rate Check Spec for Ceded Policies Need?
- Which Shortcuts Make Bordereau Rate Checks Fail?
- What Does a Filled Rate Check Show for a Policy Ceded at 1.2 Per Mille?
- What Should a Reinsurer Do When a Ceded Policy Fails the Rate Check?
- How Does Insurnest Support Rate Checks on Reinsurance Bordereaux?
- Key Terms
- Sources
- Frequently Asked Questions
Last reviewed: November 2026
A USD 5m warehouse is ceded at 1.2 per mille when the cedent's own rate guide says 2.0.
That is USD 4,000 of gross premium missing on one line, and the portfolio average will never show it.
Rate checks on reinsurance bordereaux compare the rate implied by each ceded policy with the rate the guide expected.
This guide gives you a rule spec to build today, the exceptions it must allow and a filled example with exact arithmetic.
Key Takeaways
- Check each row, not the average. A class can hit its average rate while single risks sit far below guide.
- Normalise before comparing. Convert per mille and percent, strip fees and annualise short periods first.
- Allow named exceptions only. Minimum premiums, short-period scales and approved referrals, each with a code.
- Act on the pattern. One cheap policy is a query; a cluster is a treaty conversation.
Why Do Rate Checks on Reinsurance Bordereaux Work at Policy Level?
Rate checks on reinsurance bordereaux work at policy level because an average can sit on target while single risks are underpriced.
Exposure to premium reconciliation tests whether total premium fits total exposure. A rate check asks the same of each row.
Under a quota share, the reinsurer takes its share of whatever rate the cedent charged.
The CAS text Basic Ratemaking notes that premium is generally calculated from a rate per unit of exposure.
A rate check reverses that sum. It divides premium by exposure and compares the answer with the guide.
What Fields Does a Rate Check Spec for Ceded Policies Need?
A rate check spec for ceded policies needs eleven fields: some set the expected rate, some rebuild the actual one.
| Field | Rule | Why it matters | Example value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Class or occupancy | Map to one row of the rate guide | Wrong class means wrong expected rate | Warehouse, non-hazardous goods |
| Sum insured band | Band as defined in the guide | Guides often step rates by size | USD 1m to 10m |
| Guide version | Version in force at policy inception | Guides change mid-year | v3, from 1 April 2026 |
| Expected rate and basis | Rate plus a ‰ or % flag | 2.0‰ and 2.0% differ tenfold | 2.0‰ |
| Sum insured | Same basis the guide rates on | A first-loss limit inflates the implied rate | USD 5,000,000 |
| Gross premium | Before tax, policy fees and levies | Fees inflate small-policy rates | USD 6,000 |
| Days on cover | Expiry date minus inception date | Short periods need annualising | 365 |
| Implied annual rate | Premium × (365 ÷ days) ÷ sum insured × 1,000 | Puts every row on one ‰ basis | 1.2‰ |
| Rate tolerance | Band agreed per class | Stops noise from small discounts | ±15% |
| Exception code | MIN, SP, REF or blank | Lets approved deviations pass with a reason | Blank |
| Outcome | Pass, below, above or exception | Drives the query list | Below by 40% |
Lloyd's Coverholder Reporting Standards carry sum insured and gross premium as separate fields.
So the implied rate can be rebuilt without a rate column. See bordereau template mapping for column mapping.
Which expected rate source should a bordereau rate check use?
A bordereau rate check should use the rate guide given to reinsurers at placement, in the version in force at each inception.
Ask for the guide as a table of class, band, rate and basis. If a class has no rate, record "no expected rate".
How should premium and rate basis be normalised before a rate check?
Premium and rate basis should be normalised to one annual, fee-free per mille rate before any comparison.
Per mille means per 1,000 of sum insured, so 2.0‰ equals 0.20%. A rate column reading 0.2 could be either.
Strip fees, taxes and levies, then annualise. A 182-day policy at USD 3,000 has an annualised premium of about USD 6,016.
What tolerance should a bordereau rate check allow?
A bordereau rate check should allow a tolerance agreed per class, wide enough for discretion and tight enough to catch undercharging.
The ±15% here is illustrative. Agree it alongside any risk-adjusted rate change assumed at renewal.
Which exceptions should a rate check let through with a reason code?
A rate check should let through minimum premiums, short-period scales and approved referrals, each with an exception code.
The CAS text lists the minimum premium among rules a rating manual sets. Rows priced by rule need codes, not queries.
- Minimum premium (MIN). A USD 250,000 risk at 2.0‰ prices at USD 500; a USD 750 minimum makes it 3.0‰.
- Short-period premium (SP). Short-period scales often charge above pro rata, so the implied annual rate runs high.
- Approved referral (REF). A below-guide rate signed off by the cedent's authority holder, with the reference on the row.
Which Shortcuts Make Bordereau Rate Checks Fail?
Bordereau rate checks fail through shortcuts that compare unlike numbers.
- Comparing to the average. A class average of 1.9‰ says nothing about a single row at 1.2‰.
- Ignoring rate basis. A cedent switching from ‰ to % mid-year makes every row fail, or worse, pass.
- Using today's guide. Policies incepting before a guide change must be tested on the old version.
- Testing premium with fees in. Small policies then look overpriced and bury the cheap large ones.
What Does a Filled Rate Check Show for a Policy Ceded at 1.2 Per Mille?
A filled rate check for a policy ceded at 1.2 per mille shows a USD 4,000 gross premium gap on a single warehouse.
The case is illustrative: a 50% quota share with a 30% ceding commission and a USD 5m sum insured.
What premium did the rate guide expect on the ceded USD 5m warehouse?
The rate guide expected USD 10,000 of annual premium on the ceded USD 5m warehouse: 5,000,000 × 2.0 ÷ 1,000.
What premium did the bordereau actually cede on the warehouse?
The bordereau ceded USD 6,000 of fee-free premium on the warehouse for a full year.
That is an implied rate of 1.2‰ (6,000 ÷ 5,000,000 × 1,000), 40% below guide and outside the ±15% band.
How large is the premium shortfall on a warehouse ceded at 1.2 per mille?
The premium shortfall on a warehouse ceded at 1.2 per mille is USD 4,000 gross, or USD 1,400 net to the reinsurer.
| Line | At guide rate (2.0‰) | As ceded (1.2‰) | Premium shortfall |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gross premium, 100% | USD 10,000 | USD 6,000 | USD 4,000 |
| Reinsurer's 50% share | USD 5,000 | USD 3,000 | USD 2,000 |
| Ceding commission at 30% | USD 1,500 | USD 900 | USD 600 |
| Net premium to reinsurer | USD 3,500 | USD 2,100 | USD 1,400 |
The reinsurer's share of a total loss is USD 2.5m either way. Only the premium changed.
What Should a Reinsurer Do When a Ceded Policy Fails the Rate Check?
A reinsurer should query a ceded policy that fails the rate check, then decide on the pattern rather than the single row.
- Query the row. Send the policy reference, expected rate, implied rate and tolerance to the cedent.
- Accept valid reasons. A missed exception code, a first-loss basis or a referral reference closes it.
- Track repeats. Group failures by class, producer and underwriter; a cluster says more than one row.
- Check the treaty. Proportional treaties rarely let a reinsurer reject one risk; wording varies, so check your contract.
- Use it at renewal. Failures by class feed the rate guide review and the commission discussion.
For binders, Lloyd's MS3 Price and Rate Monitoring expects leaders to act when rating conditions deviate adversely.
Amending rating schedules is one action it names.
Rate checks sit beside treaty exclusion checks at cession: one asks if a risk belongs, the other if it was priced as agreed.
How Does Insurnest Support Rate Checks on Reinsurance Bordereaux?
Reinsurance Bordereaux Reconciliation does not run rate checks against a cedent's guide. That test stays with your team.
It calculates each reinsurer's share of premium and claims from the configured participation.
It compares those values with bordereaux, premium and settlement records, flags differences and shows status by reinsurer.
The platform identifies the difference. Finance teams find out why the rate differs.
See also reconciliation variance root cause and bordereau resubmission handling.
Key Terms
- Implied rate: Annualised, fee-free premium divided by sum insured, shown per mille or per cent.
- Rate tolerance: The agreed band around the expected rate.
- Short-period premium: Premium for cover shorter than a year, often charged above pro rata.
Sources
- Lloyd's: MS3 Price and Rate Monitoring (minimum standards, PRM 2.2 on delegated authority pricing)
- Lloyd's: Coverholder Reporting Standards User Guide (Version 5.2, August 2019)
- Casualty Actuarial Society: Basic Ratemaking (G. Werner and C. Modlin, 5th edition, May 2016)
- Insurnest: Reinsurance Bordereaux Reconciliation
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do rate checks on reinsurance bordereaux work at policy level?
Rate checks on reinsurance bordereaux work at policy level because an average rate can sit on target while single risks are ceded far below the cedent's rate guide.
What fields does a rate check spec for ceded policies need?
A rate check spec for ceded policies needs class, size band, guide version, expected rate and basis, sum insured, fee-free premium, days on cover, implied rate, tolerance, exception code and outcome.
How should premium and rate basis be normalised before a rate check?
Premium and rate basis should be normalised to one annual, fee-free per mille rate: strip fees and taxes, annualise short periods and convert percentage rates.
What tolerance should a bordereau rate check allow?
A bordereau rate check should allow a tolerance agreed per class with the treaty underwriter, wide enough for normal discounts and narrow enough to catch undercharging.
Which exceptions should a rate check let through with a reason code?
A rate check should let through minimum premiums, short-period scales and approved referrals, each with a reason code, so the query list holds only real failures.
Which shortcuts make bordereau rate checks fail?
Bordereau rate checks fail when teams compare to the average rate, ignore the rate basis, use today's guide for older policies or test premium that still includes fees.
How large is the premium shortfall on a warehouse ceded at 1.2 per mille?
The premium shortfall on a USD 5m warehouse ceded at 1.2 per mille against a 2.0 guide is USD 4,000 gross, or USD 1,400 net to a 50% quota share reinsurer.
What should a reinsurer do when a ceded policy fails the rate check?
A reinsurer should query a ceded policy that fails the rate check, accept valid reasons, track repeat failures by class and producer, and take the pattern to renewal.

Hitul Mistry
CEO, Insurnest
An InsurTech leader with more than a decade of experience across insurance and technology, focused on solving business problems with the help of technology. Has worked with brokers, insurance carriers, and reinsurance firms across the India, UAE, and US markets.
View LinkedIn profile →