Auditor Information Requests for Reinsurers: Evidence Map
On this page
- Key Takeaways
- Why Do Auditor Information Requests for Reinsurers Pile Up at Year End?
- What Do Auditors Ask Reinsurers for on Treaty Balances?
- How Should Each Family of Audit Requests Be Answered?
- Which Auditor Requests Should a Reinsurer Prepare First?
- How Should a Reinsurer Log Open Auditor Requests?
- How Can a Reinsurer Test Last Year's Audit Requests Before Year End?
- How Does Insurnest Support Auditor Information Requests for Reinsurers?
- Key Terms
- Sources
- Frequently Asked Questions
Last reviewed: November 2026
"Please send the ceded premium recalculation for every retro treaty, with support, by Friday."
The request lands on 12 January. The treaty terms sit in PDFs, the shares in a spreadsheet and the calculations in someone's head.
Auditor information requests for reinsurers are the evidence requests an external audit team sends on treaty balances.
They are predictable. Most repeat every year, so the evidence can be mapped before the auditor asks.
This guide gives you a request catalogue, a triage order, a request log and a dry-run method.
Key Takeaways
- Requests repeat. Last year's list is the best forecast of this year's.
- Every request has a source record. Map it, name an owner and agree the evidence format.
- Confirmations go first. Third-party replies take longest and the auditor controls the process.
- Recalculations need terms. No auditor can recalculate a balance without the treaty rule behind it.
Why Do Auditor Information Requests for Reinsurers Pile Up at Year End?
Auditor information requests for reinsurers pile up at year end because treaty balances rest on several moving parts.
- Third parties. Cedents, brokers and retrocessionaires must confirm balances, on their own timetable.
- Estimates. Premium estimates, IBNR and reinstatement premiums change until the books close.
- Contract terms. Shares, commission rules and endorsements sit in slips, wordings and emails.
- People. The person who set up a treaty may have moved on, taking the reasoning with them.
Gathering all four under deadline is what turns a routine audit into a scramble.
What Do Auditors Ask Reinsurers for on Treaty Balances?
Auditors ask reinsurers for eight families of evidence on treaty balances. The catalogue maps each to its source.
| Auditor request | What the auditor tests | Source record | Owner | Evidence to hand over |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Balance confirmations | Existence and accuracy of balances with cedents, brokers and retrocessionaires | Counterparty ledger | Technical accounting | Counterparty list with balances and contacts |
| Ceded premium recalculation | Ceded premium follows treaty share and base | Treaty terms, premium ledger | Retro accounting | Recalculation tied to the ledger |
| Commission recalculation | Ceding, sliding scale and profit commission | Treaty commission rules | Technical accounting | Rule, inputs, result, booking |
| Reinstatement premiums | Premium due after losses is booked | Loss to layer, treaty terms | Claims and technical accounting | Calculation per layer and event |
| Ceded IBNR support | Reinsurers' share of IBNR is reasonable | Reserving output, treaty terms | Actuarial | Method, shares, reconciliation |
| Collateral | Collateral held or posted exists | LOCs, trust and funds withheld | Treasury | Bank confirmations, LOC copies |
| Contract evidence | Balances rest on agreed terms | Slips, wordings, endorsements | Underwriting operations | Signed contracts and amendments |
| Claims recoverables | Retro recoveries on paid and outstanding claims are valid | Claims ledger, retro terms | Claims and retro accounting | Claims listing tied to ledger, with retro share |
How Should Each Family of Audit Requests Be Answered?
Each family of audit requests should be answered from its source record, with the calculation shown and tied to the ledger.
How should reinsurers handle auditor balance confirmation requests?
Reinsurers should handle auditor balance confirmation requests by supplying clean lists early and leaving control with the auditor.
ISA (UK) 505 defines an external confirmation as evidence obtained as a direct written response from a third party.
The standard requires the auditor to maintain control over external confirmation requests. Do not send them yourself.
The auditor may send positive requests that leave the balance blank, so the counterparty fills it in. Expect that format.
If management refuses to let the auditor send a request, the auditor must ask why and seek other evidence.
The international version is ISA 505 from the IAASB. See also reinsurance balance confirmation.
What support do auditors need for premium and commission recalculations?
Auditors need the treaty terms, the premium base, the share and the commission rule for premium and commission recalculations.
Take an illustrative 25% quota share retro on a USD 120m assumed property book. Ceded premium is USD 30m.
At 30% retro commission, commission is USD 9m. If the ledger used an estimate of USD 110m, ceded premium shows USD 27.5m.
The auditor's ceded premium recalculation finds premium USD 2.5m short, and commission USD 0.75m short (30% × 2.5m).
Commission rules are covered in ceding commission accrual.
How should reinstatement premiums be evidenced for the auditor?
Reinstatement premiums should be evidenced with the loss to the layer, the treaty terms and the booking.
On an illustrative USD 20m xs USD 5m layer with USD 2.4m premium, a USD 8m loss to the layer gives USD 0.96m.
That is USD 2.4m × 8/20, at 100% pro rata as to amount. Method detail is in reinstatement premium calculation.
What IBNR and collateral evidence do auditors ask reinsurers for?
IBNR and collateral evidence auditors ask reinsurers for covers the method behind ceded IBNR and proof that collateral exists.
For ceded IBNR, show how gross IBNR was split by treaty share; see IBNR allocation to reinsurers.
For collateral, hand over LOC copies and bank confirmations; see reinsurance letter of credit tracking.
Which contract evidence satisfies an auditor's request for treaty terms?
Contract evidence that satisfies an auditor is the signed slip or wording, with every endorsement in force at the balance sheet date.
An unsigned draft invites follow-up. Reinsurance contract certainty explains why signatures matter.
Which Auditor Requests Should a Reinsurer Prepare First?
A reinsurer should prepare the requests that depend on third parties first and the internal estimates last.
- Balance confirmation lists. Replies take weeks, so lists should be ready before year end.
- Contract evidence. Missing signatures need the broker or counterparty to fix.
- Premium and commission recalculations. Internal, but they need clean treaty terms.
- Reinstatement premiums. Depend on final loss figures for the year.
- Ceded IBNR and collateral. Follow the reserving and treasury close.
How Should a Reinsurer Log Open Auditor Requests?
A reinsurer should log open auditor requests in one shared audit request log, one line per request.
AUDIT REQUEST LOG - FY2026
Ref Request Treaty / scope Owner Due Evidence sent Auditor sign-off
AR-01 Balance confirmation list All counterparties [Name] 15.12 List v2, 10.12 Open
AR-02 Ceded premium recalculation Retro QS 2026 [Name] 20.01 Recalc + ledger tie Cleared 22.01
AR-03 Reinstatement premium support Cat XoL layer 2 [Name] 20.01 Calc per event Query raised
How Can a Reinsurer Test Last Year's Audit Requests Before Year End?
A reinsurer can test last year's audit requests before year end with a dry run on a recent quarter.
- Take last year's request list from the auditor's final schedule.
- Pick the 30 September balances and rerun each request.
- Time each one. Anything over two days needs a fix before year end.
- Note every request that needed a person to explain a number. That is a gap in the record.
- Record where the evidence came from, so next year starts from a map.
- Agree evidence formats with the audit manager in the planning meeting.
How Does Insurnest Support Auditor Information Requests for Reinsurers?
Reinsurance Treaty Management holds treaty terms, shares, commission rules and calculation logic in one record.
It applies configured formulas, such as ceded premium = GWP × ceded share, and keeps calculation history and an audit trail.
Controlled versions show which terms applied at the balance sheet date.
It does not send confirmations, hold collateral or produce IBNR. Accuracy depends on configuration, and teams validate results.
Key Terms
- External confirmation: Audit evidence obtained as a direct written response to the auditor from a third party.
- Ceded IBNR: The share of incurred but not reported claims expected to be recovered from reinsurers.
- Audit request log: A list of open auditor requests with owner, due date and status.
Sources
- Financial Reporting Council: ISA (UK) 505, External Confirmations (revised October 2023, updated October 2025)
- IAASB: External Confirmations (ISA 505)
- Insurnest: Reinsurance Treaty Management
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do auditor information requests for reinsurers pile up at year end?
Auditor information requests for reinsurers pile up at year end because treaty balances depend on third parties, estimates and contract terms held in several places.
What do auditors ask reinsurers for on treaty balances?
Auditors ask reinsurers for balance confirmations, premium and commission recalculations, reinstatement premiums, IBNR support, collateral, contract evidence and claims recoverables.
How should reinsurers handle auditor balance confirmation requests?
Reinsurers should handle auditor balance confirmation requests by giving the auditor clean counterparty lists and contacts early, while the auditor keeps control of sending and receiving.
What support do auditors need for premium and commission recalculations?
Auditors need the treaty terms, the premium base used, the share, the commission rule and a recalculation that ties to the ledger, for premium and commission recalculations.
How should reinstatement premiums be evidenced for the auditor?
Reinstatement premiums should be evidenced for the auditor with the loss to the layer, the treaty reinstatement terms, the calculation and the booking that records it.
Which auditor requests should a reinsurer prepare first?
A reinsurer should prepare balance confirmation lists first, then contract evidence, then recalculations, then estimates such as IBNR, because third-party replies take the longest.
How should a reinsurer log open auditor requests?
A reinsurer should log open auditor requests with a reference, the request, the treaty, the owner, the due date, the evidence sent and the auditor's sign-off.
How can a reinsurer test last year's audit requests before year end?
A reinsurer can test last year's audit requests before year end by rerunning each request on a recent quarter and timing how long the evidence takes to produce.

Hitul Mistry
CEO, Insurnest
An InsurTech leader with more than a decade of experience across insurance and technology, focused on solving business problems with the help of technology. Has worked with brokers, insurance carriers, and reinsurance firms across the India, UAE, and US markets.
View LinkedIn profile →