Reinsurance Balance Confirmation: A CFO's Pre-Audit Guide
On this page
- Key Takeaways
- What Is a Reinsurance Balance Confirmation?
- Which Reinsurance Balances Should We Confirm, and When?
- What Should a Reinsurance Balance Confirmation Request Contain?
- Why Do Confirmed Balances Disagree?
- Who Should Own Each Difference?
- Should We Run Confirmations in Spreadsheets or on a Platform?
- Where Does Insurnest Fit in Balance Confirmation?
- What Should the CFO Decide Before Year-End?
- Key Terms
- Sources
- Frequently Asked Questions
Last reviewed: November 2026
Auditors find a reinsurance balance you cannot explain, and the year-end timetable starts to slip.
Most of those differences were visible months earlier, if anyone had asked the counterparty.
Reinsurance balance confirmation means agreeing the balance with each reinsurer, cedent or broker at a set date, split by treaty, year and currency.
Run it before the auditor does, explain every difference with evidence, and give each unresolved item an owner.
Key Takeaways
- Confirm before the auditor confirms. Your own process clears timing items early.
- Split the balance into components. Premium, claims, commission and cash differ for different reasons.
- Explain differences to zero. Reconciling items should add up to the gap, with evidence.
- Give every difference an owner and an age. Ageing shows which items are becoming problems.
What Is a Reinsurance Balance Confirmation?
A reinsurance balance confirmation is a written agreement with a counterparty on the balance outstanding between you at a set date.
It covers reinsurers, cedents and brokers, and it should be split by treaty, underwriting year and currency.
How does it differ from the auditor's external confirmation?
The company's own balance confirmation is a management control.
The auditor's external confirmation is audit evidence the auditor obtains directly from the third party.
The two work together. If your confirmation has already cleared the differences, the auditor's request is less likely to come back as an exception.
Audit expectations have also risen in the UK. The FRC published a revised ISA (UK) 505 on external confirmations in October 2023.
It prohibits negative confirmations and adds enhanced requirements for investigating exceptions.
According to ICAEW, it applies to audits of periods beginning on or after 15 December 2024.
Which Reinsurance Balances Should We Confirm, and When?
The reinsurance balances to confirm are those that are material, aged, disputed or held with counterparties of concern.
Confirming everything every quarter rarely adds value.
How should counterparties be prioritised?
Counterparties should be prioritised by size and risk, so effort follows exposure. The tiers below are illustrative.
| Tier | Criteria | Frequency | Method |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Largest balances or any disputed item | Quarterly | Full component split, signed response |
| 2 | Mid-sized, active treaties | Half-yearly | Component split by treaty |
| 3 | Small or run-off balances | Annually | Total balance by currency |
| Watch | Weak credit, aged items or slow payers | Quarterly, whatever the size | Full split plus ageing |
What as-at date works best?
The best as-at date is usually a quarter-end before year-end, such as 30 September.
Differences found then can be cleared before the year-end close, and the year-end balance is rolled forward from an agreed position.
Should broker balances be confirmed separately?
Broker balances should be confirmed separately whenever money passes through a broker.
Premium may be paid to the broker but not yet passed on. The broker and the reinsurer can then each hold a valid but different view.
Our guide to reinsurance broker balance reconciliation covers this in detail.
What Should a Reinsurance Balance Confirmation Request Contain?
A reinsurance balance confirmation request should contain enough detail for the counterparty to agree or disagree line by line.
This template works for most treaties.
| Field | Why it is needed |
|---|---|
| Legal entities on both sides | Avoids confusion within groups |
| As-at date | Fixes the point both sides compare |
| Treaty, underwriting year and section | Lets each line be traced |
| Currency | Balances should be confirmed in original currency |
| Premium balance | Separates premium from claims timing |
| Claims balance | Paid claims recoverable or payable |
| Commission and adjustments | Often booked at different times |
| Cash received but not allocated | Shows unmatched payments openly |
| Total balance and direction | Who owes whom, and how much |
| Reply-by date and contact | Sets a deadline and a named person |
Why break the balance into components?
Breaking the balance into components matters because premium, claims and commission differ for different reasons.
A single net total can hide two large errors that cancel each other out.
Why Do Confirmed Balances Disagree?
Confirmed balances disagree mainly because of timing, not error. Both sides can be right on the day and still show different numbers.
Here is a hypothetical example for one reinsurer:
| Item | Amount (illustrative) |
|---|---|
| Our balance: due from Reinsurer X | 1,240,000 |
| Reinsurer X's confirmed balance | 1,050,000 |
| Difference to explain | 190,000 |
| Cash in transit: paid 30 December, received 3 January | 120,000 |
| Claim note issued 28 December, not yet booked by Reinsurer X | 85,000 |
| FX: our closing-rate revaluation is lower than their figure | -15,000 |
| Explained total (120,000 + 85,000 − 15,000) | 190,000 |
| Unexplained | 0 |
The first two items are timing and will clear in January. The FX item is a policy difference that needs a note, not a correction.
Most differences fall into five types, and each type has a natural owner:
| Difference type | Typical example | Who resolves it | Evidence to keep |
|---|---|---|---|
| Timing | Cash or notes in transit at the as-at date | Reinsurance accounting | Bank statement, note date |
| FX | Different rates or revaluation policies | Reinsurance accounting, treasury | Rate source on both sides |
| Share | Written line used instead of signed line | Reinsurance accounting, underwriting | Final signed line |
| Allocation | Cash posted to the wrong treaty or year | Reinsurance accounting | Remittance advice |
| Dispute | Claim or adjustment not accepted | Claims or underwriting | Correspondence and decision |
Timing and FX items should clear or be documented. Share, allocation and dispute items need a correction or a decision.
How much unexplained difference can we accept?
The acceptable unexplained difference is a tolerance the CFO sets in advance, tied to materiality and counterparty size.
Track small unexplained amounts anyway. A balance that drifts every quarter often hides a share or allocation error.
The FX revaluation of reinsurance balances is a frequent source of such drift.
Who Should Own Each Difference?
Each difference should have one named owner in reinsurance accounting, even when another team resolves it.
Claims, underwriting or treasury fix items in their area, and the owner tracks each one to closure.
When should a difference reach the CFO?
A difference should reach the CFO when it is material, disputed by the counterparty or older than an agreed age, such as two quarters.
Escalation rules set in advance stop large items from waiting until audit.
What will the auditor expect to see?
The auditor will expect a reconciliation for each material counterparty, with every reconciling item evidenced and aged.
Audit-ready reinsurance reporting explains how to keep that evidence together.
Should We Run Confirmations in Spreadsheets or on a Platform?
Confirmations can run in spreadsheets, but the starting balance matters more than the tool. A confirmation sent from an unreconciled balance invites disagreement.
| Factor | Email and spreadsheets | Reconciled positions plus a defined process |
|---|---|---|
| Starting balance | Ledger figure, often unreconciled | Reinsurer-level position already reconciled |
| Component split | Built by hand each time | Taken from structured data |
| Differences | Found when the reply arrives | Many found before the request is sent |
| Ageing and ownership | Tracked in a separate sheet | Tracked against each position |
| Effort at year-end | Peaks sharply | Spread across the year |
Where Does Insurnest Fit in Balance Confirmation?
Insurnest fits at the step before the request is sent. Bordereaux Calculation & Reconciliation calculates premium and claim allocation per reinsurer.
It reconciles those figures against bordereaux, master data, premium and claim registers, and settlement advices in one variance view.
Status is shown per reinsurer, such as "3 of 4 positions matched". That is the position a reinsurance balance confirmation should start from.
It does not send confirmation requests or chase replies. It detects mismatches, and your accounting team determines their cause and how to resolve them.
What Should the CFO Decide Before Year-End?
The CFO should make four decisions before year-end, so the confirmation cycle runs without debate.
- Tiers: Which counterparties are confirmed, how often and in what detail.
- As-at date: A pre-year-end date that leaves time to clear differences.
- Tolerance: The unexplained amount that can be accepted per counterparty.
- Escalation: Who sees material, disputed or aged differences, and when.
Key Terms
- Balance confirmation: Written agreement of an outstanding balance with a counterparty at a set date.
- External confirmation: Audit evidence an auditor obtains directly from a third party.
- Reconciling item: A documented reason two parties' balances differ.
- Cash in transit: Money paid by one side but not yet received by the other.
- Ageing: How long a balance or difference has been outstanding.
- Unallocated cash: Money received but not yet matched to a note or balance; see unallocated cash in reinsurance.
Sources
- Financial Reporting Council: FRC Publishes Revised ISA (UK) 505 External Confirmations (3 October 2023)
- ICAEW: Updating and enhancing external audit confirmations (14 March 2024)
- Insurnest: Bordereaux Calculation & Reconciliation
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a reinsurance balance confirmation?
A reinsurance balance confirmation is a written agreement with a counterparty, such as a reinsurer, cedent or broker, on the balance outstanding between you at a set date. Good confirmations split the balance by treaty, underwriting year, currency and component, so differences can be traced quickly.
Why should insurers confirm reinsurance balances before audit?
Insurers should confirm reinsurance balances before audit because unexplained differences found by auditors take longer and cost more to resolve. Running your own confirmations first lets the team clear timing items, correct errors and show auditors a clean, documented reconciliation for each material counterparty.
How do you explain a difference in a reinsurance balance confirmation?
Explaining a difference in a reinsurance balance confirmation means listing each reconciling item, such as cash in transit, notes not yet booked, FX differences or share errors, with evidence. The explained items should add up to the difference, and anything left over is the unexplained amount to investigate.
Who should own reinsurance balance differences?
Reinsurance balance differences should be owned by the reinsurance accounting team, with one named person per counterparty. Claims, underwriting or treasury resolve items in their area, and the financial controller reviews ageing. Material or disputed differences should go to the CFO before the year-end close.
How much unexplained difference is acceptable in a balance confirmation?
An acceptable unexplained difference in a balance confirmation is one below a tolerance the CFO has set in advance, usually tied to materiality and counterparty size. Even small unexplained amounts should be tracked, because a balance that keeps drifting often hides a systematic share or allocation error.
Can reinsurance balance confirmation be automated?
Reinsurance balance confirmation can be partly automated by producing reconciled positions per counterparty, preparing requests from templates and matching responses. People still need to chase replies, investigate exceptions and decide how to book corrections, especially for disputed or aged items.
How does a balance confirmation differ from an auditor's external confirmation?
A balance confirmation run by the company is a management control used to agree balances with counterparties. An auditor's external confirmation is audit evidence the auditor obtains directly from a third party. Doing your own first means the auditor's requests are less likely to return exceptions.
Should broker balances be confirmed separately from reinsurer balances?
Broker balances should be confirmed separately from reinsurer balances when premium or claims pass through a broker. Money can be paid to the broker but not yet passed on, so the broker and the reinsurer can each hold a different, valid view of the same transaction.

Hitul Mistry
CEO, Insurnest
An InsurTech leader with more than a decade of experience across insurance and technology, focused on solving business problems with the help of technology. Has worked with brokers, insurance carriers, and reinsurance firms across the India, UAE, and US markets.
View LinkedIn profile →