Treaty Wording Circulation by Reinsurance Brokers: A Runbook
On this page
- Key Takeaways
- What Is Treaty Wording Circulation by Reinsurance Brokers?
- What Are the Stages of Treaty Wording Circulation From Draft to Issued Contract?
- What Goes Wrong When Brokers Circulate Treaty Wordings to Many Markets?
- What Should a Treaty Wording Comment Log Record?
- How Does Insurnest Support Treaty Records After the Wording Is Agreed?
- Key Terms
- Sources
- Frequently Asked Questions
Last reviewed: November 2026
Version 3 of the property catastrophe wording went to eleven markets on a Tuesday. By Friday, two followers had marked up version 2.
The lead had agreed a new hours clause by email that nobody else saw. At inception, nobody could say which text the panel had agreed.
Treaty wording circulation by reinsurance brokers is the controlled path from first draft to one wording every reinsurer has agreed.
It matters because a panel that confirms different drafts has no single contract to rely on when a claim arrives.
This guide gives you a five-stage runbook with owners, a RACI grid, a comment log template and an escalation ladder.
Key Takeaways
- One live version only. Each circulation round supersedes the last, by number.
- Comments go in a log. An email thread is not a record of what changed.
- Silence is not agreement. Every following reinsurer confirms the final text in writing.
- Close before inception. Contract certainty means terms agreed when the contract starts.
What Is Treaty Wording Circulation by Reinsurance Brokers?
Treaty wording circulation by reinsurance brokers is the round of sending draft wordings to the lead and followers for comment and agreement.
It starts once slip terms are agreed. It ends when every market confirms one numbered final version.
Why does treaty wording circulation decide contract certainty?
Treaty wording circulation decides contract certainty because the wording is where every agreed term is finally written down.
Lloyd's defines contract certainty as "complete and final agreement of all terms" by the time the parties enter the contract.
Documentation should follow "promptly thereafter", under a market Code of Practice that Lloyd's says was reissued in September 2018.
The RAA glossary notes that temporary placement slips are used less because of contract certainty initiatives.
The principle itself is covered in reinsurance contract certainty.
What Are the Stages of Treaty Wording Circulation From Draft to Issued Contract?
The stages of treaty wording circulation run from first draft to filed final wording, each with one owner and one piece of evidence.
The time limits below are illustrative internal targets, not market rules. Set your own in your broking procedures.
| Stage | Trigger | Action | Owner | Approver | Evidence | Time limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Draft | Slip terms agreed with the lead | Draft v1 from the slip, clause by clause | Wording team | Placing broker | v1 with slip cross-reference | 5 working days after firm order |
| 2. Comment | v1 sent to all markets | Each reinsurer returns marked-up comments | Wording team | None | Comment log rows per market | 10 working days |
| 3. Consolidate | Comment window closes | Resolve comments; issue v2 with a change list | Wording team | Lead on disputed clauses | v2 and resolved log | 5 working days |
| 4. Agree | v2 issued | Lead, then followers, confirm the numbered version | Placing broker | Each reinsurer for its own line | Written confirmations quoting the version | Before inception |
| 5. Issue and file | All confirmations in | Issue final, send to cedent, file with slip | Wording team | Placing broker | Final PDF, confirmation list, file date | 2 working days |
Every stage names the version number. A reply that says "agreed" without one is not evidence.
Who signs off each version of a circulated treaty wording?
Sign-off on each version of a circulated treaty wording depends on the activity, so use a RACI grid rather than one name.
| Activity | Wording team | Placing broker | Lead reinsurer | Following reinsurers | Cedent |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Draft v1 against slip | R | A | C | I | C |
| Collect market comments | R | A | C | C | I |
| Resolve disputed clauses | R | A | C | C | C |
| Confirm final version | I | A | R (own line) | R (own line) | C |
| Issue and file | R | A | I | I | I |
R = responsible, A = accountable, C = consulted, I = informed.
The HMRC Lloyd's Manual glossary says followers must follow the lead "as regards the rate of premium".
Other wording points need each market's own agreement, unless the slip delegates them to the lead. Record that delegation clause.
What Goes Wrong When Brokers Circulate Treaty Wordings to Many Markets?
Brokers circulating treaty wordings to many markets lose control at the handoffs between versions, people and inboxes.
- Version fork. A follower comments on v1 after v2 has gone out.
- Side agreement. The lead accepts a change by phone, and the log never shows it.
- Silent follower. One market never replies, and silence is booked as agreement.
- Slip drift. The wording quietly differs from the slip on hours, limits or exclusions.
- Renumbered clauses. Comments point to clause 12, which is now clause 13.
- Late cedent view. The cedent sees the final text only after inception.
Record each gap against the slip in a treaty wording deviation log.
How should a broker escalate a following reinsurer that has not responded to a wording?
A broker should escalate a following reinsurer that has not responded to a wording on a fixed ladder tied to inception.
| Point | Action | By |
|---|---|---|
| Comment window closes | Named reminder quoting version and deadline | Wording team |
| +3 working days | Call the follower's underwriter; log the call | Placing broker |
| +5 working days | Email the follower's contract wording lead | Broking director |
| 10 working days before inception | Tell the cedent which lines are unconfirmed | Placing broker |
| Inception | Record open lines as exceptions with an action date | Broking director |
Never mark a line agreed on silence. Agreement is a written reply that quotes the version number.
What Should a Treaty Wording Comment Log Record?
A treaty wording comment log should record every comment by market, clause and version, with its resolution and who accepted it.
TREATY WORDING COMMENT LOG
Treaty / UMR : [Cedent] [Treaty] [Inception] / [ref]
Version commented : v[n] issued [date]
Comment ID : [market code]-[number]
Market : [reinsurer], [lead | follower], [contact]
Clause : [number] [title] (as in v[n])
Comment : [requested change, quoted]
Slip reference : [slip line it relates to, or "new term"]
Resolution : [accepted | rejected | amended | withdrawn]
Agreed by : [lead | all markets | cedent], [date]
Lands in : v[n+1], clause [number]
One row per comment keeps the trail intact when clauses are renumbered.
The "Lands in" line is what stops a version fork: every comment points forward to the consolidated draft.
How do you consolidate conflicting market comments on one treaty clause?
To consolidate conflicting market comments on one treaty clause, trace each back to the slip, then put one proposed text to every market.
- Check the slip. If the slip already settles the point, the wording follows the slip.
- Check authority. If the slip lets the lead agree that point, the lead's position goes in.
- Otherwise draft a compromise. Send it to all markets with the competing comments shown.
- Record the outcome. Note which markets accepted which text, by version.
Illustrative example: one follower asks for a 96-hour windstorm clause, another for 168 hours. The slip says 72, so the wording says 72.
How Does Insurnest Support Treaty Records After the Wording Is Agreed?
Reinsurance Treaty Management does not circulate wordings, collect market comments or chase reinsurers.
It holds a controlled digital record per treaty: structure, terms and conditions, participation, retention and limits.
As agreed terms are amended, it keeps controlled treaty versions with an audit trail. Teams still check configured terms against the final wording.
For the move from text to records, see treaty wordings to systems and reinsurance placement handoffs.
Key Terms
- Contract certainty: Complete and final agreement of all terms by the time the contract is entered.
- Comment log: A per-comment record of market requests, resolutions and the version each lands in.
- Following reinsurer: A market that subscribes after the lead, on its own line.
Sources
- Lloyd's: Contract certainty
- HMRC: Lloyd's Manual glossary (LLM11000)
- Reinsurance Association of America: Glossary of reinsurance terms
- Insurnest: Reinsurance Treaty Management
Frequently Asked Questions
What is treaty wording circulation by reinsurance brokers?
Treaty wording circulation by reinsurance brokers is the round of sending draft treaty wordings to lead and following reinsurers, resolving their comments and issuing one numbered final version.
Why does treaty wording circulation decide contract certainty?
Treaty wording circulation decides contract certainty because the wording records every agreed term. Lloyd's defines contract certainty as complete and final agreement of all terms when the contract is entered.
What are the stages of treaty wording circulation from draft to issued contract?
The stages of treaty wording circulation are draft, comment, consolidate, agree and issue. Each stage needs one owner, one approver, dated evidence and a time limit set before inception.
Who signs off each version of a circulated treaty wording?
Sign-off on each version of a circulated treaty wording sits with the placing broker as accountable owner, while each reinsurer confirms its own line in writing against a version number.
What goes wrong when brokers circulate treaty wordings to many markets?
When brokers circulate treaty wordings to many markets, the usual failures are version forks, side agreements, silent followers, slip drift, renumbered clauses and a cedent who sees the text too late.
How should a broker escalate a following reinsurer that has not responded to a wording?
A broker should escalate a following reinsurer that has not responded to a wording on a fixed ladder: reminder, call, director email, cedent notice 10 working days before inception, then a logged exception.
What should a treaty wording comment log record?
A treaty wording comment log should record each comment's market, clause, version, requested change, slip reference, resolution, who agreed it and the version and clause where it lands.
How do you consolidate conflicting market comments on one treaty clause?
To consolidate conflicting market comments on one treaty clause, check the slip first, then the lead's delegated authority, then send one compromise text to all markets and record each acceptance.

Hitul Mistry
CEO, Insurnest
An InsurTech leader with more than a decade of experience across insurance and technology, focused on solving business problems with the help of technology. Has worked with brokers, insurance carriers, and reinsurance firms across the India, UAE, and US markets.
View LinkedIn profile →