Negative Premiums in Reinsurance Bordereaux: Decision Table
On this page
- Key Takeaways
- Why Do Negative Premiums in Reinsurance Bordereaux Need a Decision Before Booking?
- Which Decision Table Separates Genuine Returns From Data Errors?
- Which Negative Premiums Are Genuine Returns?
- Which Negative Premiums on a Bordereau Are Data Errors?
- How Should Negative Premium Decisions Be Recorded?
- How Does Insurnest Help With Negative Premiums in Bordereaux?
- Key Terms
- Sources
- Frequently Asked Questions
Last reviewed: November 2026
Quarter close is on Friday. The motor bordereau holds 214 rows of negative premium, totalling USD −386,500.
Some are cancellations and some are mistakes. They all look the same: a minus sign.
Negative premiums in reinsurance bordereaux are rows that reduce ceded premium, either as genuine returns or as data errors.
This guide gives you a decision table, the evidence to ask for, who signs off and a numeric case for each branch.
Key Takeaways
- A minus sign is a claim, not a fact. Every negative row needs a reason.
- Match to the original row. A genuine return points back to premium already ceded.
- Read the transaction type and date. They separate most errors from returns.
- Record the decision. Auditors will ask why each one was booked.
Why Do Negative Premiums in Reinsurance Bordereaux Need a Decision Before Booking?
Negative premiums in reinsurance bordereaux need a decision because returns and errors look identical once booked.
A genuine return reduces ceded premium correctly.
An error understates it, and the gap may surface only at ceded premium leakage reviews.
Solvency II Delegated Regulation 2015/35, Article 19 treats data as accurate when it is free from material errors.
Which Decision Table Separates Genuine Returns From Data Errors?
The decision table below separates genuine returns from data errors by the evidence each one should come with.
| Situation | Evidence to ask for | Decision | Who signs off |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cancellation | Original positive row, cancellation date, return basis | Book return at the original ceded share | Bordereaux analyst |
| Mid-term reduction | Endorsement, new sum insured, effective date | Book return premium | Bordereaux analyst |
| Adjustment refund | Adjustment calculation, minimum premium clause | Book, capped at the minimum | Treaty underwriter and technical accounting |
| Correction of prior over-cession | Original cession, correct share, period corrected | Book as referenced prior-period correction | Head of technical accounting |
| Sign flip | Transaction type is original premium | Reject; request corrected row | Bordereaux team lead |
| Duplicated reversal | Two rows with same policy, date and amount | Book once; request correction | Bordereaux team lead |
| Wrong period | Effective date outside the reporting period | Move to the right period or hold | Technical accounting |
| Credit note booked twice | Credit note reference matches bordereau rows | Book through one route only | Technical accounting |
Lloyd's Coverholder Reporting Standards v5.2 list return premium as a transaction type.
They also define an effective date of transaction, such as the date of a cancellation. Ask cedents for both fields.
Send one evidence request per bordereau, listing row references and the branch you suspect.
Cedents answer one numbered list faster than a stream of single queries.
Which Negative Premiums Are Genuine Returns?
Negative premiums are genuine returns when they reverse premium already ceded for a reason the policy or treaty allows.
Cases below use a 30% quota share and are illustrative. Treaty wording varies; check your contract.
How should a negative premium from a cancellation be checked?
A negative premium from a cancellation should be checked against the original positive row and the cancellation date.
A USD 12,000 policy ceded USD 3,600. Cancelled after 146 of 365 days, 219 days are unearned, which is 60%.
Gross return is USD 7,200 and the ceded return USD −2,160 (3,600 × 0.60). Earning basis is covered in earned premium calculation.
How should a mid-term reduction be checked on a bordereau?
A mid-term reduction on a bordereau should be checked against the endorsement and its effective date.
Sum insured falls from USD 2.0m to 1.5m with half the term left. At a 0.2% rate, annual premium drops from USD 4,000 to 3,000.
The gross return is USD 500 (1,000 × 0.5) and the ceded return USD −150.
When is a negative premium adjustment capped by the minimum premium?
A negative premium adjustment is capped by the minimum premium when adjusted premium falls below that minimum.
Deposit premium is USD 1.2m and minimum USD 1.0m. Rate × actual GNPI gives USD 0.95m.
The refund is USD 200,000 (1.2m − 1.0m), not USD 250,000. Booking the larger figure understates premium by USD 50,000.
How should a correction of prior over-cession be booked?
A correction of prior over-cession should be booked as a referenced correction to the period it fixes.
In Q2, USD 500,000 was ceded at 40% instead of 30%: USD 200,000 instead of 150,000. The Q3 correction is USD −50,000, referenced to Q2.
Which Negative Premiums on a Bordereau Are Data Errors?
Negative premiums on a bordereau are data errors when no policy event or treaty term supports the minus sign.
How is a sign flip spotted on a premium bordereau?
A sign flip is spotted on a premium bordereau when original premium for a new policy shows as negative.
A new policy ceding USD 3,600 appears as USD −3,600. Ceded premium is understated by USD 7,200, twice the row's value.
The automated rule is simple: transaction type is original premium and the amount is below zero.
How is a duplicated reversal spotted on a bordereau?
A duplicated reversal is spotted on a bordereau when two negative rows share policy, effective date and amount.
The USD −2,160 cancellation above appears twice, so USD −4,320 is booked.
Similar logic applies to duplicate claim payments in reinsurance.
What makes a negative premium a wrong-period entry?
A negative premium is a wrong-period entry when its effective date falls outside the bordereau's reporting period.
A cancellation effective 15 October 2026 in a July to September bordereau belongs in Q4. See date sequence anomalies.
How does a credit note get booked twice in reinsurance?
A credit note gets booked twice in reinsurance when the same return arrives through the account and the bordereau.
A USD −18,000 credit note is settled through the statement, while the bordereau rows also total USD −18,000. USD −36,000 is booked.
See reinsurance debit and credit notes for one-route booking.
How Should Negative Premium Decisions Be Recorded?
Negative premium decisions should be recorded in one log per bordereau, kept with the reconciliation file.
NEGATIVE PREMIUM LOG
Bordereau: [cedent / treaty / period] Prepared by: [name]
Row ref | Policy | Amount | Branch (1-8) | Evidence received |
Decision (book / reject / move / hold) | Approver | Date
Here is the log summary for the opening motor bordereau, with illustrative figures.
| Branch | Rows | Amount (USD) | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cancellations and reductions matched to original rows | 188 | −291,700 | Booked |
| Prior over-cession correction | 1 | −50,000 | Booked, referenced to Q2 |
| Duplicated reversals | 14 | −24,800 | Rejected; correction requested |
| Wrong period | 9 | −11,400 | Moved to Q4 |
| Sign flips | 2 | −8,600 | Rejected; corrected rows requested |
| Total | 214 | −386,500 |
USD −341,700 is booked this quarter. The other USD −44,800 is not, and each row's reason is on file.
Errors go back to the cedent through bordereau resubmission handling. Patterns go to reconciliation variance root cause.
How Does Insurnest Help With Negative Premiums in Bordereaux?
Reinsurance Bordereaux Reconciliation splits premium, including returns, and claims by configured reinsurer share.
It compares calculated values with bordereaux, master, premium and settlement records, and flags differences for investigation.
It does not decide whether a return is genuine. It shows the gap, and finance decides why it exists.
Key Terms
- Return premium: Premium given back after a cancellation, reduction or adjustment.
- Over-cession: Premium ceded at a higher share than the treaty provides.
- Effective date of transaction: The date a change, such as a cancellation, takes effect.
Sources
- Lloyd's: Coverholder Reporting Standards User Guide, Version 5.2 (20 August 2019)
- EIOPA Solvency II rulebook: Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/35, Article 19
- Insurnest: Reinsurance Bordereaux Reconciliation
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do negative premiums in reinsurance bordereaux need a decision before booking?
Negative premiums in reinsurance bordereaux need a decision before booking because genuine returns and data errors look identical as a minus sign, but only returns should reduce ceded premium.
How should a negative premium from a cancellation be checked?
A negative premium from a cancellation should be checked against the original positive row, the cancellation date and the return basis, then recalculated at the original ceded share.
When is a negative premium adjustment capped by the minimum premium?
A negative premium adjustment is capped by the minimum premium when the adjusted premium falls below it. The refund then stops at deposit less minimum, subject to the wording.
How should a correction of prior over-cession be booked?
A correction of prior over-cession should be booked as a referenced prior-period correction, showing the original share, the correct share and the period it corrects.
How is a sign flip spotted on a premium bordereau?
A sign flip is spotted on a premium bordereau when a row typed as original premium for new business carries a negative amount.
How is a duplicated reversal spotted on a bordereau?
A duplicated reversal is spotted on a bordereau when two negative rows share the same policy, effective date and amount without two matching endorsements.
How does a credit note get booked twice in reinsurance?
A credit note gets booked twice in reinsurance when the cedent issues it through the account and also includes the same return rows in the bordereau.
How should negative premium decisions be recorded?
Negative premium decisions should be recorded in a log showing row reference, amount, decision branch, evidence received, decision, approver and date, so auditors can trace each one.

Hitul Mistry
CEO, Insurnest
An InsurTech leader with more than a decade of experience across insurance and technology, focused on solving business problems with the help of technology. Has worked with brokers, insurance carriers, and reinsurance firms across the India, UAE, and US markets.
View LinkedIn profile →