How to Select an Actuary for Your Pet Insurance MGA Program
How to Select an Actuary for Your Pet Insurance MGA Program
An actuary is one of the first professionals you need on your team. They develop the pricing that makes your program financially viable, produce the rate filings regulators require, and provide the loss reserve opinions carriers demand. Choosing the right actuary can make or break your program's first years.
Why Does a Pet Insurance MGA Need an Actuary?
A pet insurance MGA needs an actuary because state regulators require actuarial memorandums and rate certifications for rate filings, fronting carriers demand actuarial rate support and reserve opinions before approving programs, and sound actuarial analysis is the foundation for setting competitive yet profitable prices. Without qualified actuarial support, you cannot file rates, secure a carrier, or project your financial performance accurately.
1. Regulatory Requirements
State insurance departments require actuarial support for:
- Rate filings — Actuarial memorandums supporting proposed rates
- Rate adequacy — Certification that rates are adequate, not excessive, and not unfairly discriminatory
- Loss reserves — IBNR (Incurred But Not Reported) reserve estimates
- Actuarial opinions — Some states require a signed Statement of Actuarial Opinion
2. Carrier Requirements
Your fronting carrier will require:
- Actuarial rate support before approving your program
- Quarterly or annual loss reserve reviews
- Trend analysis and rate adequacy monitoring
- Support for carrier actuarial audits
3. Business Needs
Beyond regulatory compliance, actuarial analysis helps you:
- Set prices that are competitive yet profitable
- Understand your loss cost structure
- Project financial performance for your business plan
- Make data-driven underwriting decisions
What Actuarial Credentials Should You Look For?
For a pet insurance MGA, look for an FCAS (Fellow of the Casualty Actuarial Society) or ACAS (Associate) with MAAA (Member of the American Academy of Actuaries) membership. FCAS is the highest P&C actuarial credential and is required for signing certain regulatory opinions, while ACAS holders can perform most day-to-day pricing and analysis work.
1. FCAS (Fellow of the Casualty Actuarial Society)
- Highest P&C actuarial credential
- 7–10 years of exams plus experience requirements
- Can sign actuarial opinions and certifications
- Required for certain regulatory filings
- Preferred for lead actuarial roles
2. ACAS (Associate of the Casualty Actuarial Society)
- Intermediate P&C credential
- 4–6 years of exams plus experience
- Can perform most actuarial work
- Cannot sign certain state-required opinions
- Suitable for day-to-day pricing and analysis
3. Other Credentials
- FSA/ASA — Society of Actuaries (life and health focus, less relevant for pet P&C)
- MAAA — Member of the American Academy of Actuaries (required to sign opinions)
For a pet insurance MGA, look for: FCAS or ACAS with MAAA membership.
How Do You Find the Right Actuary for Your Pet Insurance Program?
Finding the right actuary involves choosing between large consulting firms and boutique consultants based on your budget, then evaluating candidates on P&C experience, specialty lines knowledge, startup comfort, regulatory familiarity, and communication skills. Prioritize actuaries who have worked with limited data and can support both regulatory filings and carrier reviews.
1. Consulting Firms vs Individual Consultants
Consulting Firms
- Milliman, Willis Towers Watson, Pinnacle Actuarial Resources, Oliver Wyman
- Broader resources, multiple actuaries available
- Higher rates ($300–$600/hour)
- Better for ongoing, complex programs
Boutique and Individual Consultants
- Specialty P&C actuarial firms
- More personalized attention
- Lower rates ($200–$400/hour)
- May have pet insurance or specialty lines experience
- Better for startup MGAs with budget constraints
2. Evaluation Criteria
When interviewing potential actuaries, assess:
- P&C experience — Must have property-casualty background (not life/health)
- Specialty lines experience — Pet insurance, niche P&C, or health-adjacent lines
- Startup experience — Comfort working with limited data and making assumptions
- Regulatory knowledge — Familiar with SERFF filings and state DOI requirements
- Carrier relationships — Experience supporting carrier actuarial reviews
- Communication — Ability to explain complex concepts to non-actuaries
- Responsiveness — Startup timelines require quick turnarounds
- Cost — Fits within your startup budget
3. Questions to Ask
- Have you priced pet insurance before? If not, what analogous products have you worked with?
- How would you approach rate development with no proprietary claims data?
- What data sources would you use for pet insurance pricing benchmarks?
- Can you sign the actuarial opinions required for rate filings?
- What is your typical turnaround time for rate indications?
- How do you handle carrier actuarial reviews?
What Actuarial Deliverables Does a New MGA Need?
A new pet insurance MGA needs pre-launch deliverables including a rate indication study ($10K–$40K) and financial projections ($5K–$15K), followed by ongoing post-launch deliverables including quarterly reserve reviews ($3K–$8K per quarter), annual rate reviews ($5K–$15K per year), and ad hoc support for carrier inquiries and product expansion.
1. Pre-Launch Deliverables
Rate Indication Study ($10K–$40K)
- Base rate development by coverage type
- Rating variables (breed, age, geography, deductible, coverage limit)
- Rate relativities and rating algorithm
- Actuarial memorandum for rate filings
Financial Projections ($5K–$15K)
- Expected loss ratios by product and year
- Premium adequacy testing
- Sensitivity analysis on key assumptions
- Support for financial model
2. Post-Launch Deliverables (Ongoing)
Quarterly Reserve Reviews ($3K–$8K per quarter)
- IBNR reserve estimates
- Loss development analysis
- Case reserve adequacy review
- Reserve range estimates
Annual Rate Reviews ($5K–$15K per year)
- Emerging experience analysis
- Trend factor updates
- Rate adequacy assessment
- Rate change recommendations
Ad Hoc Support ($2K–$10K as needed)
- Carrier actuarial inquiries
- Regulatory objection responses
- Product expansion pricing
- Reinsurance treaty support
How Should You Work Effectively with Your Actuary?
To work effectively with your actuary, provide clean claims and policy data in a consistent format, set clear expectations on deliverables and timelines upfront, establish a regular monthly or quarterly review cadence, and invest in a long-term relationship. The best actuarial partnerships develop over years as the actuary learns your business, builds historical knowledge, and provides increasingly valuable analysis.
1. Provide Good Data
Your actuary needs:
- Claims data (frequency, severity, development patterns)
- Policy data (exposure counts, premium, coverage details)
- Veterinary cost benchmarks
- Competitor rate filings (publicly available through SERFF)
- Industry data from NAPHIA
2. Set Clear Expectations
- Define deliverables and timelines upfront
- Establish a regular review cadence (monthly or quarterly)
- Agree on data format and delivery schedule
- Clarify who signs actuarial opinions
3. Build a Long-Term Relationship
The best actuarial relationships are ongoing partnerships:
- The actuary learns your business over time
- Historical knowledge improves future analysis
- Consistent methodology builds regulatory credibility
- Long-term engagement is more cost-effective than project-by-project
For the complete actuarial pricing framework, see our guide on actuarial pricing basics.
Frequently Asked Questions
What credentials should a pet insurance actuary have?
Look for an FCAS (Fellow of the Casualty Actuarial Society) or ACAS (Associate) designation. FCAS is preferred for signing actuarial opinions. The actuary should have P&C experience, ideally with specialty lines.
What actuarial deliverables does a new pet insurance MGA need?
Essential deliverables include rate indications, actuarial memorandum for rate filings, loss development patterns, IBNR reserve estimates, and trend factor analysis.
How much does actuarial support cost for a pet insurance MGA?
Initial rate development costs $15,000–$60,000. Ongoing support costs $10,000–$30,000 per year.
Can a new MGA use industry data instead of proprietary data for pricing?
Yes, new MGAs can use NAPHIA industry benchmarks, competitor filings, and veterinary cost data. The actuary applies credibility weighting to blend industry data with emerging proprietary experience.
Should I hire a large actuarial consulting firm or a boutique consultant?
Large firms like Milliman and Willis Towers Watson offer broader resources and multiple actuaries but charge $300–$600/hour. Boutique and individual consultants provide more personalized attention at $200–$400/hour and may have specific pet insurance experience. Boutique firms are often better for startup MGAs with budget constraints.
What questions should I ask when interviewing potential actuaries?
Key questions include: Have you priced pet insurance before? How would you approach rate development with no proprietary claims data? What data sources would you use? Can you sign the actuarial opinions required for rate filings? What is your typical turnaround time? How do you handle carrier actuarial reviews?
How often does an MGA need actuarial support after launch?
After launch, MGAs typically need quarterly reserve reviews ($3K–$8K per quarter), annual rate reviews ($5K–$15K per year), and ad hoc support ($2K–$10K as needed) for carrier inquiries and product expansion pricing.
What is the difference between FCAS and ACAS credentials?
FCAS (Fellow of the Casualty Actuarial Society) is the highest P&C actuarial credential requiring 7–10 years of exams, and the holder can sign all actuarial opinions. ACAS (Associate) is an intermediate credential requiring 4–6 years of exams and can perform most actuarial work but cannot sign certain state-required opinions.
External Sources
Internal Links
- Explore Services → https://insurnest.com/services/
- Explore Solutions → https://insurnest.com/solutions/
