Pet Insurance MGA Annual Report: What to Include and How to Present It
Your annual report is the most important document you'll share with your carrier each year. It's your opportunity to tell the story of your program the wins, the challenges, the data, and the vision. A great annual report builds carrier confidence, demonstrates operational maturity, and sets the stage for next year's growth. A weak one raises questions you don't want asked.
Talk to Our Specialists
How Should You Structure an MGA Annual Report?
An MGA annual report should follow a clear structure that moves from high-level results to detailed analysis: executive summary, financial performance, operational metrics, growth analysis, market analysis, strategic initiatives, challenges and remediation, next-year plan, and appendix. This structure allows each audience carrier, board, or team to find the information most relevant to them.
1. Section Overview
| Section | Pages | Purpose |
|---|
| Executive summary | 1–2 | High-level results and key messages |
| Financial performance | 3–5 | Premium, loss ratio, profitability |
| Operational metrics | 3–5 | Claims, service, compliance |
| Growth analysis | 2–3 | New business, retention, expansion |
| Market analysis | 1–2 | Industry context, competitive position |
| Strategic initiatives | 2–3 | What you did this year |
| Challenges and remediation | 1–2 | Honest assessment of problems |
| Next-year plan | 2–3 | Strategy, targets, investments |
| Appendix | As needed | Detailed data tables |
2. Timeline
| Activity | Timing | Owner |
|---|
| Begin data compilation | January 15 | Finance + analytics |
| First draft | February 15 | Leadership |
| Internal review | February 28 | Leadership team |
| Final report | March 15 | CEO |
| Carrier presentation | March–April | CEO + leadership |
| Board presentation | April–May | CEO + CFO |
| Team presentation | January–February | CEO |
The financial performance section should cover gross written premium, earned premium, policies in force, incurred claims, loss ratio, commission revenue, profit commission, net revenue, operating expenses, and net income all with prior-year comparisons and target benchmarks. This section is the most scrutinized by carriers and investors, so accuracy and context are critical.
1. Key Financial Metrics
| Metric | Prior Year | Current Year | Change | Target |
|---|
| Gross written premium | $ | $ | % | $ |
| Earned premium | $ | $ | % | $ |
| Policies in force (year-end) | # | # | % | # |
| Incurred claims | $ | $ | % | — |
| Loss ratio | % | % | Δ pts | <65% |
| Commission revenue | $ | $ | % | $ |
| Profit commission | $ | $ | % | $ |
| Net revenue | $ | $ | % | $ |
| Operating expenses | $ | $ | % | $ |
| Net income | $ | $ | % | $ |
2. Loss Ratio Analysis
| Dimension | Loss Ratio | Prior Year | Trend |
|---|
| Overall | % | % | ↑↓ |
| By product tier | % each | % each | ↑↓ |
| By state (top 5) | % each | % each | ↑↓ |
| By policy year (vintage) | % each | % each | ↑↓ |
| New business only | % | % | ↑↓ |
| Renewal only | % | % | ↑↓ |
3. Premium Growth Analysis
| Metric | Value | Commentary |
|---|
| New business premium | $ | Growth driver analysis |
| Renewal premium | $ | Retention impact |
| Rate change impact | $ | Premium from rate increases |
| State expansion impact | $ | Premium from new states |
| Cancellation impact | ($) | Premium lost to churn |
| Net premium change | $ | Total YoY change |
For carrier reporting requirements, see our reporting guide.
What Operational Metrics Should the Report Cover?
The operational metrics section should cover claims performance (processing time, denial rate, satisfaction), customer metrics (retention, NPS, complaint ratio), and compliance performance (licensing, audit results, regulatory actions). These metrics demonstrate operational maturity and directly influence carrier confidence in your MGA's ability to manage their program effectively.
| Metric | Target | Actual | Prior Year |
|---|
| Claims count | — | # | # |
| Average processing time | <7 days | X days | X days |
| Claims >14 days | <5% | % | % |
| Denial rate | 12–18% | % | % |
| Appeal overturn rate | 15–25% | % | % |
| Customer satisfaction (claims) | >85% | % | % |
2. Customer Metrics
| Metric | Target | Actual | Prior Year |
|---|
| Retention rate | >85% | % | % |
| NPS | >40 | # | # |
| Customer satisfaction (overall) | >85% | % | % |
| Complaint ratio | <1/1,000 | X/1,000 | X/1,000 |
| DOI complaints | 0 | # | # |
| Element | Status |
|---|
| Licensing | Current in all X states |
| Rate filings | All current |
| Carrier audit results | Findings: X (all remediated) |
| Regulatory actions | None (or details) |
| Internal audits | Conducted per schedule |
| Compliance training | 100% completion |
For carrier audit preparation, see our audit guide.
How Should You Analyze and Present Growth?
Growth analysis should break down business development by channel, geographic expansion by state, and retention by tenure and reason for non-renewal. Presenting growth with this level of detail allows carriers and investors to understand where volume is coming from, which channels are most efficient, and where the biggest opportunities lie for the next year.
1. Business Development
| Channel | Policies | Premium | % of Total | Growth |
|---|
| Direct (website) | # | $ | % | % |
| Agent channel | # | $ | % | % |
| Partner/affiliate | # | $ | % | % |
| Employer | # | $ | % | % |
| Total | # | $ | 100% | % |
2. Geographic Expansion
| State Activity | Count | Premium Impact |
|---|
| States operating (start of year) | # | — |
| New states launched | # | $ new premium |
| States operating (end of year) | # | — |
| Top growth states | List | $ each |
3. Retention Analysis
| Metric | Value | Commentary |
|---|
| Overall retention rate | % | Trend and drivers |
| Retention by tenure | % by year | Loyalty curve |
| Non-renewal reasons | Distribution | Top 3 reasons |
| Save rate | % of cancel requests saved | Retention team impact |
| Premium retention ratio | % | Including rate changes |
What Should the Strategic Review Section Include?
The strategic review section should include market context (industry size, growth trends, vet cost inflation), competitive positioning against key competitors, and a summary of key achievements with quantified impact. This section positions your MGA within the broader market and demonstrates strategic awareness that carriers and investors value when evaluating program viability.
1. Market Context
| Element | Data Point | Source |
|---|
| U.S. pet insurance market size | $ | NAPHIA |
| Market growth rate | % | NAPHIA |
| Pet ownership trends | # pets, % insured | APPA, NAPHIA |
| Competitive landscape | Key competitor moves | Market intelligence |
| Regulatory developments | New regulations, state activity | Industry monitoring |
| Vet cost inflation | % | BLS, industry data |
2. Competitive Position
| Factor | Our MGA | Competitor A | Competitor B |
|---|
| Premium rank | # | # | # |
| Growth rate | % | % (est.) | % (est.) |
| Product breadth | Plans | Plans | Plans |
| Claims speed | X days | X days (est.) | X days (est.) |
| Customer satisfaction | NPS # | NPS # (est.) | NPS # (est.) |
| States available | # | # | # |
3. Key Achievements
| Achievement | Impact |
|---|
| (List 5–8 key accomplishments) | Quantify impact |
| Example: Launched 5 new states | $X premium added |
| Example: Reduced claims time 30% | CSAT improved X points |
| Example: Achieved 88% retention | $X premium retained |
How Should You Address Challenges and Lessons Learned?
Challenges should be addressed honestly with quantified impact, specific actions taken, and current status (resolved or ongoing). Carriers and investors respect transparency hiding problems erodes trust, while proactive disclosure with data-backed remediation plans demonstrates operational maturity and accountability.
1. Honest Assessment
| Challenge | Impact | Action Taken | Status |
|---|
| (List challenges honestly) | Quantify impact | What you did | Resolved/ongoing |
| Example: Loss ratio spike in Q2 | LR +5 points | Rate filing + claims review | Improving |
| Example: Agent channel underperformance | Below target | Restructured incentives | Ongoing |
2. Lessons Learned
| Lesson | How It Applies Going Forward |
|---|
| (Key lessons from the year) | Operational changes |
What Should the Next-Year Plan Include?
The next-year plan should include specific, measurable targets for premium growth, policies in force, loss ratio improvement, retention, state expansion, and NPS. It should also outline the top 3–5 strategic priorities with descriptions, investment requirements, and expected measurable outcomes, plus any investment requests with purpose, amount, and projected ROI.
1. Targets
| Metric | Current Year Actual | Next Year Target | Growth |
|---|
| Gross written premium | $ | $ | % |
| Policies in force | # | # | % |
| Loss ratio | % | % | Improvement |
| Retention rate | % | % | Improvement |
| New states | # launched | # to launch | — |
| NPS | # | # | Improvement |
2. Strategic Priorities
| Priority | Description | Investment | Expected Impact |
|---|
| (Top 3–5 priorities) | Specific initiative | $ and resources | Measurable outcome |
| Example: Expand to 10 new states | Geographic growth | $X + 2 FTE | $X premium |
| Example: Launch direct pay | Claims experience | $X tech investment | +3 NPS points |
3. Investment Requests
| Request | Purpose | Amount | ROI |
|---|
| Technology | Specific upgrade/capability | $ | Expected return |
| Staffing | Roles and rationale | $ | Capacity increase |
| Marketing | Campaign or channel | $ | Expected premium |
What Are the Best Practices for Presenting to Carriers?
The best practices for carrier presentations include leading with data and results, being honest about challenges, presenting data-backed remediation plans, demonstrating market knowledge, asking for carrier input, and ending with a clear next-year vision. Structure the meeting as a 60-minute presentation followed by 30 minutes of open Q&A, and send the written report in advance.
1. Carrier Presentation Best Practices
| Do | Don't |
|---|
| Lead with results (data first) | Start with excuses |
| Be honest about challenges | Hide problems (they'll find them) |
| Show data-backed remediation | Present vague plans |
| Demonstrate market knowledge | Ignore competitive context |
| Ask for carrier input and feedback | Treat it as one-way presentation |
| End with clear next-year vision | Leave them uncertain about direction |
| Element | Duration | Content |
|---|
| Opening | 5 minutes | Executive summary, key messages |
| Financial review | 15 minutes | Premium, loss ratio, profitability |
| Operations | 10 minutes | Claims, service, compliance |
| Growth | 10 minutes | Channels, states, retention |
| Challenges | 5 minutes | Honest assessment + remediation |
| Next year | 10 minutes | Strategy, targets, requests |
| Q&A | 30 minutes | Open discussion |
For KPI metrics and tracking, see our metrics guide.
Talk to Our Specialists
Frequently Asked Questions
What should you include in an MGA annual report?
Executive summary, financial performance, operational metrics, growth analysis, compliance summary, strategic review, challenges, and next-year plan.
Who is the audience for an MGA annual report?
Carrier leadership (primary), board/investors, internal team. Tailor content to each audience's priorities.
How do you present the annual report to carriers?
60-minute presentation + 30-minute Q&A. Lead with results, be honest about challenges, present data-backed plans, end with vision.
When should you prepare the annual report?
Start January. Draft by mid-February. Carrier presentation March–April. Board in April–May.
How many pages should an MGA annual report be?
Typically 15–25 pages including appendix. Executive summary 1–2 pages, financials 3–5 pages, operational metrics 3–5 pages, with the rest covering growth, strategy, and next-year planning.
What financial benchmarks should you compare against?
NAPHIA industry averages for loss ratio (60–70%), retention (75–85%), and growth. Also compare against your prior-year performance, carrier targets, and competitor data.
Should the report include bad news?
Yes. Carriers respect transparency. Include a dedicated section for challenges with quantified impact and specific remediation actions.
How do you make the annual report actionable?
Include a next-year plan with specific, measurable targets tied to investment requirements and expected ROI for each strategic priority.
External Sources
Internal Links
